Lead dust plume

455 Bravo Uniform

Final Approach
Joined
Aug 18, 2015
Messages
7,017
Location
KLAF
Display Name
455 Bravo Uniform
Home Airfield
KLAF
Anyone planning their flight to avoid this tomorrow? Thought it was interesting from a ground deposition standpoint, but maybe from an aviation exposure standpoint as well. I don’t know much about it, have not looked into it.
 
According to ChatGPT, this is the equivalent of 0.78% of the amount of lead released by burning 100LL annually in USA.
Good Lord...detonating 9500 lbs of lead azide will release about 6755 lbs of finely-dispersed elemental lead. That's gonna cause a serious contamination problem downwind. The army is going to be on the hook for a LOT of remediation work. I live near Idaho's Silver Valley, where the lead residue from 100 years of mining created the nation's largest superfund site. Remediation in some of the towns required scraping off and removing the top 12-18" of everything, and trucking it to enormous secure landfills, replacing it all with clean dirt brought in from outside the area.

Lead azide is mighty twitchy stuff, I don't blame them for concluding it can't be moved, but some heads should roll over letting that much recrystallize unnoticed due to poor storage conditions.

Edit: OK, it has been delayed as @AV8R_87 reported. But more time is NOT going to get them to a good solution for this mess.
 
Last edited:
Honestly I’m not far from it, I was wondering if I’d be able to see it from the air.
 
Yeah, let’s blow this stuff up and let it settle over that land that grows most of our corn and soybeans. Brilliant!
 
Oh, awesome since they’ve delayed it until Monday it’s now predicted the dust is coming my way. IDK which is worse, the lead or the imminent local freak outs.
 
This seems like she sort of thing our grandkids will be effected by. Smells like a bad Idea but I cant offer a better suggestion
 
as cold as this sounds, it would be interesting to do blood lead tests now (before the explosion) and then after.
 
Will this be filed under the "Seemed like a good idea at the time!" category?
Like a certain very famous cetacean obliteration?
 
is this coming from the department of Make It Someone Else’s Problem?
How could a toxin be more safe
than confined on the ground?
 
is this coming from the department of Make It Someone Else’s Problem?
How could a toxin be more safe
than confined on the ground?

I suspect that the material is becoming more and more unstable. If left alone where it is, it is likely to explode to eventually. And apparently it is no longer safe to try to move it or make it inert.
 
According to ChatGPT, this is the equivalent of 0.78% of the amount of lead released by burning 100LL annually in USA.
Perhaps so, but this will be from a single day and localized in a part of the USA.
I suspect that the material is becoming more and more unstable. If left alone where it is, it is likely to explode to eventually. And apparently it is no longer safe to try to move it or make it inert.
This is probably true. Heavy metal azides have a nasty reputation in the lab. They are sometimes created accidentally from sodium azide. Lead azide isn't terribly soluble in water, but one way of getting rid of sodium azide (very water soluble) is to react it slowly with dilute nitrous acid.
This is not just a lead compound. It's a highly unstable lead compound. In the past was used to make exploding bullets (such as those that targeted Reagan).
Yes, very unstable.
 
According to ChatGPT, this is the equivalent of 0.78% of the amount of lead released by burning 100LL annually in USA.

did you ask chatgpt how much that will change lead levels in the environment (such as soil or groundwater)?
 
It sounds like the situation is blow it up at a time of their choosing or it blows up on its own. Better to do it on a calm day when people are mostly indoors anyway and the crops are out. I wouldn't want to be outside breathing it in, but it seems like the health risks are basically nil once it settles, except for those living right next door. I do hope (and expect) that there will be some help with remediation and testing for those folks.
 
“The dose makes the poison”

There’s going to be a lead dust exposure event. That pretty much seems inevitable.

Minimizing exposure by maximizing dilution might be part of the equation. I don’t know how high this stuff will go. Upper level winds could carry it a long way, but also have the effect of thinning it out to lower ppm levels. Could rain pull it out of the air and result in higher localized concentrations?

It does sound like it’s a matter of picking a “least worst” time to do this.
 
It sounds like the situation is blow it up at a time of their choosing or it blows up on its own. Better to do it on a calm day when people are mostly indoors anyway and the crops are out. I wouldn't want to be outside breathing it in, but it seems like the health risks are basically nil once it settles, except for those living right next door. I do hope (and expect) that there will be some help with remediation and testing for those folks.
I agree that it may be a dangerous situation. Supposedly, it was kept in a liquid that evaporated allowing the lead azide to recrystallize. If this is true, adding whatever liquid back will redissolve it allowing it to be destroyed in a similar fashion to sodium azide.

So you wouldn't mind living in the area wherever the wind blows that stuff? Say 20 miles downwind?
 
as cold as this sounds, it would be interesting to do blood lead tests now (before the explosion) and then after.

Could also take multiple surface soil and wipe samples now, then again after. Don’t necessarily need to analyze now.

Was thinking may not even need to analyze the “before” sample, just the “after” to check against published limits, but then again no amount of additional lead has been found to be beneficial (unlike other compounds).
 
That doesn't change "the dose makes the poison".

Even if there is no established "safe" threshold, more lead is still worse than less lead.

That oft used “quote” comes from compounds that have a threshold - threshold being defined from a human-health risk assessment standpoint. Lead is one compound that does not fit that quote.
 
I'm curious why lead doesn't have a safe threshold. We know it's out there in the environment, we all get exposed to it. Is it because exposure is cumulative? Is there some unique property here? Or is it simply because we knew it was bad so nobody ever tried to establish a safe level?
 
Seen a lot about the projected plume, and the pushback, but has anyone found any info on how exactly they ended up in this position?

From the bits and pieces in various articles, seems like these are ~20 year old barrels of lead azide, that are normally stored in a solution of ethanol and water. The water partially evaporated, allowing the lead azide to recrystallize?

I have a passing familiarity with explosives and storage procedures from previous jobs, but this whole situation seems pretty bizarre. Usually there are various procedures for monitoring these kinds of things while in storage, with actions to take before things get this far.
 
That oft used “quote” comes from compounds that have a threshold - threshold being defined from a human-health risk assessment standpoint. Lead is one compound that does not fit that quote.

kind of like Radon. There is no safe level for lead or Radon... or at least that's the EPA position.

However, there is a difference between safe level and level that requires action. With Radon, an action level is 4 pCi/L in a home (higher in a work environment). Now ask about the ambient Radon levels outdoors... it's not zero. the average is around 0.4 pCi/L. But there is no safe level. So we are screwed. (the suspicious thing is that the indoor action level is 10x the ambient levels outdoors...hmmmmm)

The safe level for lead is supposedly 0 ppb of lead. But bottled water is allowed to have up to 5 ppb of lead. (at least that's my understanding). So, which is it?
 
I agree that it may be a dangerous situation. Supposedly, it was kept in a liquid that evaporated allowing the lead azide to recrystallize. If this is true, adding whatever liquid back will redissolve it allowing it to be destroyed in a similar fashion to sodium azide.
I read somewhere that they are afraid to even open some of the containers, but even if the solvent could be ever-so-gently reintroduced, I suspect getting the lead azide back in solution would be a slow and at best incomplete process. The usual tricks of applying heat and stirring aren’t gonna help…

When I was in grad school, when chemistry department safety procedures were a LOT more lax than today, two old, long forgotten reagent bottles (picric acid that had dried out, and diisopropyl ether that had peroxidized) were discovered and had to be removed, I don’t recall if it was by the bomb squad or a commercial firm that did such work, but I suspect that was only after a few of the organic profs discussed getting a grad student to do it).
 
I'm curious why lead doesn't have a safe threshold. We know it's out there in the environment, we all get exposed to it. Is it because exposure is cumulative? Is there some unique property here? Or is it simply because we knew it was bad so nobody ever tried to establish a safe level?
Yes, it is cumulative. Almost all of the lead we are exposed to is from human activities.
note that decomposition of lead azide leads to an atom of lead and 2 molecules of nitrogen gas- this makes atomic lead or lead oxide (depending on how much reacts with the air). at least some of this won't be the usual lead dust that needs cleaned when dealing with lead paint.

The safe level for lead is supposedly 0 ppb of lead. But bottled water is allowed to have up to 5 ppb of lead. (at least that's my understanding). So, which is it?
It is probably because we can't really get rid of the stuff in water systems. That 5 ppb is more stringent than tap water!
 
Yes, it is cumulative. Almost all of the lead we are exposed to is from human activities.
note that decomposition of lead azide leads to an atom of lead and 2 molecules of nitrogen gas- this makes atomic lead or lead oxide (depending on how much reacts with the air). at least some of this won't be the usual lead dust that needs cleaned when dealing with lead paint.


It is probably because we can't really get rid of the stuff in water systems. That 5 ppb is more stringent than tap water!
The lead in water is almost always caused by leaching from older pipe soldering materials at the house. Which, is becoming less of a problem as that old piping is replaced. "Treatment" consists of adjusting the pH upward to make the water less corrosive. It's fairly rare to find lead present in the source water.
 
It would be useful to have some kind of way to objectively determine how concerned to be. Is this(as I suspect) basically nothing in the grand scheme of things or is laying waste to all living things like the current social media brigade seems to think.
 
Back
Top