Not exactly a glowing picture of operations for UAL UAL Law Suit I wonder if other "puppy mills" will face a similar fate now that things have slowed down?
You gotta wonder if this suit would have had any traction against a no-name school. Methinks United's pockets seemed attractive for a lawyer to pick.
I wonder if they have attracted some students who aren't sufficiently motivated or prepared to succeed in this type of program.
The school is doing a lot of outreach with its recruitment efforts. Nothing wrong with that. I'm just saying that when you are recruiting people who were not already motivated to become pilots then your drop out/wash out rate may be higher. Students who are highly self-motivated will have the highest rate of success in a difficult program.You have a good point there
The school is doing a lot of outreach with its recruitment efforts. Nothing wrong with that. I'm just saying that when you are recruiting people who were not already motivated to become pilots then your drop out/wash out rate may be higher. Students who are highly self-motivated will have the highest rate of success in a difficult program.
I don't know. The student still needs to put in the work. I've never seen a flight school, from small GA school to nationally known university, that didn't have a significant drop out rate.One would would think with a battery of test like this they could weed out future baristas pretty quickly... agree?
It’s a fact jack. I worked with a flight attendant that was accepted into the program. It wasn’t free up front but the contract was essentially you show up, we train you, If you succeed and make it to the legacy all the student debt is forgiven.The school is doing a lot of outreach with its recruitment efforts. Nothing wrong with that. I'm just saying that when you are recruiting people who were not already motivated to become pilots then your drop out/wash out rate may be higher. Students who are highly self-motivated will have the highest rate of success in a difficult program.
From what I see out there in the training pool, my bet would be that they were selecting for "least barista" out of a pool of "sub baristas", not sifting only-yeagers from otherwise capable candidate brothOne would would think with a battery of test like this they could weed out future baristas pretty quickly... agree?
“Dozens of former student pilots who say”. Why isn’t thousands? Because the dozens are the ones who just figured out they won’t be getting an airline job for maybe 5 years because the boom is over and they are upside down in debt and they got to the party too late. Nobody pushed the loans, people willingly did this to themselves.
While a shortage of training aircraft and CFIs plagued the training world since the pandemic ended, the flight schools actually did a descent job completing the huge number of students who flocked into training programs wanting high paying airline jobs. The latest hiring boom was a once in a generation event - maybe a once in multiple generation event and students today are still entering flight schools believing the boom isn’t over or will reignite.
This is the one that gets me. It feels like every 20-year-old who wants to be a pilot sees the "dream" as shuttling 150-400 people around in an airborne bus, flying the most mundane of flight profiles to prevent panicking Ma and Pa Kettle in row 28. Oh and who could forget about the paperwork, the bureaucracy, having every tiny detail of your work analyzed by the very machine you are controlling, and having it tattle on you if it didn't like something.If someone’s got the fire in their gut to chase it, and they’re a real pilot not some “captain in training” wannabe they’ll fire up Google, do the bare minimum of homework, and see aviation’s still a damn wild ride worth taking.
This is the one that gets me. It feels like every 20-year-old who wants to be a pilot sees the "dream" as shuttling 150-400 people around in an airborne bus, flying the most mundane of flight profiles to prevent panicking Ma and Pa Kettle in row 28. Oh and who could forget about the paperwork, the bureaucracy, having every tiny detail of your work analyzed by the very machine you are controlling, and having it tattle on you if it didn't like something.
Not that airline jobs should be anything but this. Their purpose is reproducible, uncompromising safety. It just seems kind of tedious and boring. It's something stable to do before retirement and after having done the job that gave you your stories for the hangar.
This month I was "bored" in Times Square and Cancun and this weekend will be bored in Punta Cana. Next month is several Punta Canas and Arubas.It just seems kind of tedious and boring.
Haha I'm sorry for your boredom, it sounds rough.This month I was "bored" in Times Square and Cancun and this weekend will be bored in Punta Cana. Next month is several Punta Canas and Arubas.
If the plaintiffs came to that expectation on their own, then they should be out of luck. If that expectation was sold to them, it will be a different story. Express warranties are difficult to disclaim.I think a lot of these students looked at the 2021-23 hiring landscape and got an unrealistic view of aviation. That was arguably one of the best times in history to get hired at a major airline. They expect 1 year zero to hero, 1 year flying RJs, then off to their major airline of choice, when in reality, that was an anomaly and they unfortunately missed that boat.
How many 20 year olds really know what they want? Some, but not many, in my experience.The question is whether a 20-year-old zero-time student really wants
Its that old adage should we be saving people from themselves but there is precedence against this type of behavior i.e Ursury laws (payday loans) and I agree that if these kids could bankrupt their ways out of these loans this would stop.Pushing a 100k loan on a kid who might not even be old enough to drink, one they can never get out of, knowing how long and hard the road will be before they even make a income they’d admit to in mixed company, that’s cool
Haha I'm sorry for your boredom, it sounds rough.
Hopefully I didn't come across as disparaging toward the airline folk. Not my intent. The question is whether a 20-year-old zero-time student really wants the seat at one of the Legacy 3 because they love flying, or because they love the idea of a half-million-dollar paycheck before age 40. The fact that so many of them are "airline or bust" is telling.
I see it in medicine all the time. There are so many med students who clearly have no real interest in the job and they barely try to hide it. I wish there was a way to make them see how miserable they are going to be 10 years from now. They think making half a mil or appeasing mommy and daddy or putting a couple fancy letters behind their name is going to make up for how much they don't actually like what they are going to have to do 8-12 hours a day, 12-20 days a month for 20+ years.
Its that old adage should we be saving people from themselves but there is precedence against this type of behavior i.e Ursury laws (payday loans) and I agree that if these kids could bankrupt their ways out of these loans this would stop.
We have the same problem in Veterinary medicine in fact so bad that the government created IBR repayment plans for this type of problem. All that did is just pass the buck down the line and this has created basically a new age "indentured servitude" to the government.
I know some law schools got sued as well
Not just aviation. It's applicable to all fields that require extensive and highly technical training (ok, so lawyers aren't that technical but the analogy is true) that too many students come in at the beginning thinking that just doing the time will get them to the big bucks. I see this in computer science at all schools other than MIT and CalTech. I've got college freshmen that don't understand how to organize the laptop desktop, forget about organizing their life.How many 20 year olds really know what they want? Some, but not many, in my experience.
There's always been a high attrition rate in this career. It takes a lot of work to succeed and that weeds out most of those who don't have a passion for it.
They might be allowed to teach, but they can't sign off anything. I'm currently working on my AGI so I'll be allowed to teach & signoff our CAP cadets to take the written. Unfortunately, I won't be allowed to teach ground at my university because they want Commercial despite I teach over in CS and understand how to teach better than most CFIs. Been doing it a lot longer, too. Oh well.The AP is a garbage agency.. the 'report' is so vague on key things.
I question the intelligence of those 'students'. This quote proves my point:
'During her eighth flight, she said, her instructor was a fellow student of the program.'
So the school was dumb enough to let a NON-CFI rated instructor to teach and sign a logbook? If this were true a simple glance at the log book by the local FSDO would shut that place down, and they would have civil penalties already. More likely it was the very common practice of the school hired a CFI who was a student building hours. Two VERY different things.
Here's another 'you have no idea WTF' quote '. 'It also alleges that students were sometimes evaluated by instructors who were not pilots themselves.' There are no FAA requirements to have a certificate to teach ground or even give a verbal evaluation. When I was at ERAU one of my math classes was taught by a 'student'... he was getting his Masters Degree at ERAU in aerodynamics... and not a pilot.
Now was this flight instruction or ground/classroom???
Sounds like the Aviate academy has the same problems of every other big box school (most flights schools even?) Too many students, not enough planes, not enough instructors, etc. I’m sure they advertised something like zero to hero in XX months with a big, fat asterisk at the end of it. Sure, you can get everything done in a year but scheduling, maintenance, weather, life, etc gets in the way. Should be interesting to see what happensIf the plaintiffs came to that expectation on their own, then they should be out of luck. If that expectation was sold to them, it will be a different story. Express warranties are difficult to disclaim.
I am glad you didn’t get scammed, but there are a lot of people who went the professional pilot program route, completed their training, got the hours teaching in the same school they attended and got quickly vacuumed up into the right seat over the last 4 years.I agree
I fly a wide body now, but it took my a while to be willing to get here, sometimes I still wonder if in would have been happier staying flying charter.
In many ways I think 135, 91, DPE work have a better QOL than 121, just depends on the person
That said I didn’t get scammed into a “cadet” program and I always try to talk to folks who want to get into the industry on tips, one of them is say NO to ATP/cadet/etc
I am glad you didn’t get scammed, but there are a lot of people who went the professional pilot program route, completed their training, got the hours teaching in the same school they attended and got quickly vacuumed up into the right seat over the last 4 years.
Aviation is a boom and bust and the first thing to go bust when the economy turn sour. If you are caught with paying loans for an occupation you can’t get hired for, times are going to be rough. Over the last 45 years there have been 4 periods that getting a pilot job was next to impossible. The next one is likely occurring in the next 12 months.
I understand what you’re saying.This is the one that gets me. It feels like every 20-year-old who wants to be a pilot sees the "dream" as shuttling 150-400 people around in an airborne bus, flying the most mundane of flight profiles to prevent panicking Ma and Pa Kettle in row 28. Oh and who could forget about the paperwork, the bureaucracy, having every tiny detail of your work analyzed by the very machine you are controlling, and having it tattle on you if it didn't like something.
Not that airline jobs should be anything but this. Their purpose is reproducible, uncompromising safety. It just seems kind of tedious and boring. It's something stable to do before retirement and after having done the job that gave you your stories for the hangar.
The dream is to make a big fat paycheck while flying. I don't think they ever think about how mind-numbingly boring most of a 12+-hour flight will be when they get to that level.This is the one that gets me. It feels like every 20-year-old who wants to be a pilot sees the "dream" as shuttling 150-400 people around in an airborne bus, flying the most mundane of flight profiles to prevent panicking Ma and Pa Kettle in row 28. Oh and who could forget about the paperwork, the bureaucracy, having every tiny detail of your work analyzed by the very machine you are controlling, and having it tattle on you if it didn't like something.
Yup.Not that airline jobs should be anything but this. Their purpose is reproducible, uncompromising safety. It just seems kind of tedious and boring. It's something stable to do before retirement and after having done the job that gave you your stories for the hangar.
If you truly love FLYING, you do crop dusting or airshows or go fly in Alaska.Hopefully I didn't come across as disparaging toward the airline folk. Not my intent. The question is whether a 20-year-old zero-time student really wants the seat at one of the Legacy 3 because they love flying, or because they love the idea of a half-million-dollar paycheck before age 40. The fact that so many of them are "airline or bust" is telling.
7-and-7 (or any similar block model) isn't your traditional banker's hours job, but a lot of people find they prefer it after making the leap. There are quite a few advantages. I have been doing block scheduling for nearly a decade, and I would never go back. It was an adjustment with the family at first, but we all came to strongly prefer it. I'm currently doing 13 on/rest of month off. I travel for work. I'm away from home 13-14 days/month, then I get the remainder of the month off, so 17ish consecutive days off. Been doing that particular schedule for over three years now. If you ever want to bounce anything off of me regarding extended blocks of work away from home, feel free to shoot me a DM.I do love flying, but I also have a family to support financially and otherwise... I'm about to find out what a 7-and-7 schedule does to us. I'd like to think that I'll still be flying into lots of new places by staying 135, but being in a jet certainly knocks down the number of places I'll be able to go. No more Montauk... And probably a lot more Teterhole.
You know... I'd like to hear everything from everyone who deals with this, so I started a new thread.7-and-7 (or any similar block model) isn't your traditional banker's hours job, but a lot of people find they prefer it after making the leap. There are quite a few advantages. I have been doing block scheduling for nearly a decade, and I would never go back. It was an adjustment with the family at first, but we all came to strongly prefer it. I'm currently doing 13 on/rest of month off. I travel for work. I'm away from home 13-14 days/month, then I get the remainder of the month off, so 17ish consecutive days off. Been doing that particular schedule for over three years now. If you ever want to bounce anything off of me regarding extended blocks of work away from home, feel free to shoot me a DM.
If you're doing a 12+ flight you're probably going to someplace interesting. I did a ferry flight (767) that was close to 11 hours but the vast majority of my flying is 7 hours or less per leg.I don't think they ever think about how mind-numbingly boring most of a 12+-hour flight will be when they get to that level.
Depends on what it is you like about flying. I like flying big airplanes and doing instrument flying. I like scoring the flight plan and making position reports over HF (well, not so much to Mumbai Radio. Can't understand a word they say.) I like landing with a 30kt crosswind or with 600 RVR. I know airline pilots who built kit planes, fly float plans in Alaska or airshows in a Pitts. That flying isn't for me.If you truly love FLYING, you do crop dusting or airshows or go fly in Alaska.
Fractional? I prefer to know where I'm going ahead of time but you'll get to go to a lot of different planes, in between stops at Teterboro, of course. Not a good fit for those who aren't interested in customer service.I'm about to find out what a 7-and-7 schedule does to us
I understand what you’re saying.
Often when I’m flying with an early 20’s FO I look at them and think about all the things I’ve done before this job. I’m not envious of them with the exception of seniority advancement. Kinda jealous of that a little. But I wouldn’t trade the experiences I’ve had to get the seniority they will have.
Are you a CFI, how many students have you trained, and have worked in a college and non college professional pilot program, a club and a mom/pop training operation?Not sure how “professional” those programs are, I’d say not very
Those same kids could have done the exact same thing, actually got more for less, at a flying club, indy CFI, mom and pop 61, etc and like half the price
Kids should be combining the flight training with a money making degree at a CC
Scam wise I can smell these people from 100 miles, when I called one curious about the scheme a month or so ago it took me like 3min to see the hook, it’s shame folks don’t do more arguing, negotiating, haggling these days, too much “stress” I guess, but costs em
The dream is to make a big fat paycheck while flying. I don't think they ever think about how mind-numbingly boring most of a 12+-hour flight will be when they get to that level.
I was 135/91/91k for over 15 years. I've been at a legacy for almost 3 years now. Best quality of life and most enjoyable flying of my career.I agree
I fly a wide body now, but it took my a while to be willing to get here, sometimes I still wonder if in would have been happier staying flying charter.
In many ways I think 135, 91, DPE work have a better QOL than 121, just depends on the person
That said I didn’t get scammed into a “cadet” program and I always try to talk to folks who want to get into the industry on tips, one of them is say NO to ATP/cadet/etc