Which model 182 do you recommend?

mooneymusher

Filing Flight Plan
Joined
Nov 13, 2026
Messages
9
Display Name
mooneymusher
Hi all, longtime lurker . I currently own a vintage Mooney. I have the opportunity to put in a 1,700’ grass strip on my property in the near future. On one end, there are trees 500’ from the end of the runway; on the other, it is flat fields.

It feels like I am taking a step backwards to move to a 182, but here are a few pros: 1. Have a two small children, loading is a challenge in the Mooney. 2. Any time we travel, there is an extra loading and unloading from the car to the airplane. If I could keep the airplane at home, it would be much more convenient. 3. Mooney on a grass strip that short is a no-go.
4. Wife would love the BRS.

So which model would fit me best?
1. I don’t have restart models money… budget 150-200k.
2. Mission is a twice a month trip with the family 200-300 miles. Once a year, 1000 miles. Otherwise, just flying around the Midwest countryside.
3. Is there something else besides a 182 that might work better?
 
Honestly, BRS is a no go for a 182. It takes up a bulk of the cargo area, and with two kids, you'll need every inch of that space. Add STOL gear and get the stall speed as low as possible, so that if the engine fails, the wings are your parachute.

The sweet spot for 182s particularly in your budget, are the P/Q models.
 
Lance.

Those kids are only gonna get bigger. And shoulder room is underrated.
 
Last edited:
For that price, P, Q, R.

BRS adds pounds. You can get an unrelated paperwork STC 150-160 lb increase for take-off (but not landing). Google Fresh Pick STC.

Compare the BRS reduced space in the 182 baggage compartment compared to the full Mooney space. There is an extended baggage option (Selkirk?) to increase space back there that may fully negate (and then some) the space loss from BRS.

Useful load is likely to be 1,000+. I’ve seen as high as 1,300’ish (@ktup-flyer). My P is 1,075ish, no wt increase STC.

Fuel burn about 13gph ROP. Long range tanks are 80-88 (90?) gallons. Figure out your legal/comfortable reserve from there for your 200-300 mile missions.

As for the Midwest country-side, I’ve puttered around at 80-90 kts and 8-9 gph when I just want to mess around. 17” MP +/-1

Something better than a 182 for all that you propose? C’mon man! :D

Math your math from there. Exciting and congrats on the upcoming runway!!
 
Last edited:
So I'm part owner in a 182P but got my HP endorsement in a 182T. Other than the upgraded avionics, from a usability standpoint, I just don't see much difference. And our 182P got new avionics a few years ago that is pretty up to date so I don't feel like I'm missing a darn thing with the P but I do feel a lot heavier in the pocket book.
 
Honestly, BRS is a no go for a 182. It takes up a bulk of the cargo area, and with two kids, you'll need every inch of that space. Add STOL gear and get the stall speed as low as possible, so that if the engine fails, the wings are your parachute.

The sweet spot for 182s particularly in your budget, are the P/Q models.
It's a personal decision that heavily depends on the type of flying and the passengers. For me, BRS is an important safety measure. For many others it may not be. It's good to have the option.
Your statement "It takes up a bulk" implies a large percentage, which it does not, especially if you have an extended baggage option.
 
Not gonna lie, as a family man with growing children and former owner of an AA5B Tiger, 182, 205, and now 206, you should just suck it up and get a 206 now.

If you stick with the 182, my vote is a P-model. It has the extra width and virtually all the refinements, but doesn't have the high-compression cylinders of a Q model. Those same high-compression cylinders mean you can't run mogas in Q models, but that is an option with the right paperwork for all of the other ones IIRC. I'd also consider a super early straight tail model for some use cases, but not yours - the extra space is meaningful.

But also, suck it up and buy a 206.
 
Not gonna lie, as a family man with growing children and former owner of an AA5B Tiger, 182, 205, and now 206, you should just suck it up and get a 206 now.

If you stick with the 182, my vote is a P-model. It has the extra width and virtually all the refinements, but doesn't have the high-compression cylinders of a Q model. Those same high-compression cylinders mean you can't run mogas in Q models, but that is an option with the right paperwork for all of the other ones IIRC. I'd also consider a super early straight tail model for some use cases, but not yours - the extra space is meaningful.

But also, suck it up and buy a 206.
Same question here. Will it be too heavy for 1700’?
 
I think it might depend on where you live. If your ogn nly option in the even of an engine out are to land in rows and rows of houses, then that brs thing might be good. If you're in the middle of farmland, then perhaps not a big deal. And it also might matter if you're flying at night. Guessing you wouldn't fly in and out of a grass field at night, but that's just a guess.

Finally, along the lines of not sure where you are, but grass fields some places can be too muddy or wet to fly out of some parts of the year...so keep that in mind. Best of luck!
 
An example of a performance chart to see what you’d be dealing with on a 1976 182P:
IMG_1635.jpeg
 
Cherokee Six?

The Hershey bar wings are better short field aircraft then the tapered wing models.

And some would say the Lyco 540 is a better engine than the Conti 470

And the 260 HP models can run mogas
 
I’m happy with my 182P. Last model for mogas, 40 Deg flaps.
Mogas was a absolute requirement for me.
Fly out of my back yard 2,000’ grass strip (9B8).
Just my wife and dog. Have a friend with three kids had to sell his 182 and move up to a 206.
Looked at the BRS. 85lbs 10 year repack, 20 year total life. You replace the whole system at 20 years.IMG_5234.jpeg
 
For a 206? Yes. If low elevation pretty much any old bird will do. At high elevation turbo.
I’ve been almost exclusively on hard surfaces. And I have had my F struggling to break ground at 1500-2000 feet on asphalt…I’m not convinced that it’s a great idea to load any old bird to max and just send it on 1700’ of turf….but I have zero experience and maybe I misunderstood you.
 
I’ve thought about it, but off 1700’ grass?
Reading is hard. Read grass but missed distance. That's a few hundred feet too close for comfort And I missed that part. But the rear doors make the loading way easier. As the kids get older I think that would be less of an issue. But the kids getting older (bigger) will be more of an issue with other planes
 
It's a personal decision that heavily depends on the type of flying and the passengers. For me, BRS is an important safety measure. For many others it may not be. It's good to have the option.
Your statement "It takes up a bulk" implies a large percentage, which it does not, especially if you have an extended baggage option.
I get that, but the chute assembly sits centered, directly behind the rear seat, partially obstructing the baggage door for anything larger, correct? I'm not saying it's not a great safety tool, but there is a cargo volume price to be paid. If you're filling all four seats, that's a real issue.

I'd love to have one, but for the 182, I'd almost rather spend the extra money trading up for a Petersen Katmai conversion. That doesn't address the pilot incapacitation issue, but it does slow the plane down enough that you can plop it down virtually anywhere.

 
but the chute assembly sits centered, directly behind the rear seat, partially obstructing the baggage door for anything larger, correct?
The factory-installed one in the T-model that I rented was offset to the copilot side. It still consumed a good chunk of baggage space, but not enough that I wouldn't cancel a family vacation. It'd probably turn an apartment move from a green light into a no-go, though.
 
I get that, but the chute assembly sits centered, directly behind the rear seat, partially obstructing the baggage door for anything larger, correct? I'm not saying it's not a great safety tool, but there is a cargo volume price to be paid. If you're filling all four seats, that's a real issue.

I'd love to have one, but for the 182, I'd almost rather spend the extra money trading up for a Petersen Katmai conversion. That doesn't address the pilot incapacitation issue, but it does slow the plane down enough that you can plop it down virtually anywhere.

Peterson no longer makes those, asked years ago.
They sell for a hefty premium
Oh so sweet for stol
 
Peterson no longer makes those, asked years ago.
They sell for a hefty premium
Oh so sweet for stol
They're not even making their own? Didn't realize that. Seems like there's always demand for them.
 
They're not even making their own? Didn't realize that. Seems like there's always demand for them.

Yeah, they stopped a few years back. Used market is in the $400-500k range. Ridiculous if you ask me and I own a Peterson 182; I considered selling as a result, but what would I replace it with?!
 
I get that, but the chute assembly sits centered, directly behind the rear seat, partially obstructing the baggage door for anything larger, correct? I'm not saying it's not a great safety tool, but there is a cargo volume price to be paid.
So the chute is at the bottom of the baggage compartment? How does that work when you pull it? Does the rocket fly through all your stuff and throw it out the back window? Where do the lines get installed?

Cessna had trouble with the 162 BRS that was mounted in the rear baggage, on one of the two they crashed, they pulled the BRS in a spin and the remnants of the back window cut all the lines on the chute. :o
 
So the chute is at the bottom of the baggage compartment? How does that work when you pull it? Does the rocket fly through all your stuff and throw it out the back window? Where do the lines get installed?

Cessna had trouble with the 162 BRS that was mounted in the rear baggage, on one of the two they crashed, they pulled the BRS in a spin and the remnants of the back window cut all the lines on the chute. :o
Vertical tube in baggage compartment with rocket pack and chute. Lines around wing at root covered with fairing strips. Goes out through omnivision windows. About 80#.
 
So the chute is at the bottom of the baggage compartment? How does that work when you pull it? Does the rocket fly through all your stuff and throw it out the back window? Where do the lines get installed?

Cessna had trouble with the 162 BRS that was mounted in the rear baggage, on one of the two they crashed, they pulled the BRS in a spin and the remnants of the back window cut all the lines on the chute. :o
Take a look at this photo: it blasts through the back window: https://www.kitplanes.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/chute_02.jpg
 
I’ve been almost exclusively on hard surfaces. And I have had my F struggling to break ground at 1500-2000 feet on asphalt…I’m not convinced that it’s a great idea to load any old bird to max and just send it on 1700’ of turf….but I have zero experience and maybe I misunderstood you.
You mean your F-model Mooney? If so, yeah, I wouldn’t be surprised. The 206 and a Mooney are about as different a design purpose as they come.

Fwiw, my 206 will be off the ground somewhere between 300’ and 1000’ depending on weight, operating almost exclusively from highish to high elevation airports. It is shocking what they will haul and how that wing lifts. To be honest, I don’t really even pay attention to liftoff distance that much because there is so much margin for most runways. I really only start even thinking about it when the strip is probably less than 1300, and only really start paying attention when it’s less than or around 1,000. There just aren’t THAT many strips less than 1,000’, but I’ve had it in and out of strips at 900’ with no problem (off in about 600’ in one case I can think of recently - that particular strip is at about 5,000’ and we were two big guys, gear, and 2/3rds fuel).

I fly almost exclusively from unimproved airstrips, btw. Turbo G model.
 
Last edited:
I'm reading this with a different perspective. Thinking that you'll be trading one set of issues for another...and potentially taking off from a marginal field with very little room for error, over and over again, with your family. None of that sounds all that fun.

So I'm instead recommending 2 airplanes. One champ, or cub if you can find a great price. Leave that at home, 1700' is great for it, and you just take one family member at a time, no baggage, and fly around for fun. One 182 to replace the Mooney at the airport with the long hard runway. Everything fits in there nicely. Sell the Mooney to a single person.

If you don't want both at once, pick which one you want first.
 
The copyright symbol in the footer of each page kinda spells it out. And its still for sale on the CPA website.
 
You mean your F-model Mooney? If so, yeah, I wouldn’t be surprised. The 206 and a Mooney are about as different a design purpose as they come.

Fwiw, my 206 will be off the ground somewhere between 300’ and 1000’ depending on weight, operating almost exclusively from highish to high elevation airports. It is shocking what they will haul and how that wing lifts. To be honest, I don’t really even pay attention to liftoff distance that much because there is so much margin for most runways. I really only start even thinking about it when the strip is probably less than 1300, and only really start paying attention when it’s less than or around 1,000. There just aren’t THAT many strips less than 1,000’, but I’ve had it in and out of strips at 900’ with no problem (off in about 600’ in one case I can think of recently - that particular strip is at about 5,000’ and we were two big guys, gear, and 2/3rds fuel).

I fly almost exclusively from unimproved airstrips, btw. Turbo G model.
I believe I misunderstood you. I took you to mean any old airplane. I believe you meant any old 206. Thank you for your insight.
 
I believe this is now in the public domain. A web search turns up multiple copies. If it is subject to copyright I will delete this post. My favorite 182 is the P model. I’ve had 2 1973 and a 1974. One with an O520 (PPonk), one with an IO520 (Airplains) and currently an IO470.

This is a great summary - I bought it before buying my P model.

Where in the midwest are you located / where will the strip be?

A bigger question is how often and how many kids will you be taking with you? If you want to do like @Jim K and be the flying Von Trapp / Partridge family / reality TV show territory flying with , you might want to extend the runway into that flat land and buy a six place something. Or a Cessna Caravan. But for up to four adults and a few things, the 182 works.

The 182 is the Toyota Camry/family SUV of the skies. Not Mooney fast but gets the job done for X Country travel (135-140 kts TAS at altitude), any mechanic can work on it, tons of spare parts, etc. Good on turf and concrete. You have two doors, lots of weight carrying options, lots of fuel load options, etc. Get's 13 GPH (11 LOP, take your pick). And you'll learn to like sitting up straight in the seats and having your own shoulder room.
 
Last edited:
My P model has been the family truckster for 19 years. I didn’t even have to contemplate W&B until my boys were mid teens and that’s because I have long range fuel. It’s been a near perfect airplane.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WDD
The copyright symbol in the footer of each page kinda spells it out. And its still for sale on the CPA website.
Clearly missed that. I was a CPA member in its previous incarnation. I deleted the link. I searched for the model year history and did not see a link to CPA. The buyer’s guide is there. I didn’t search too long though. Anyway, if you have a link to it on the CPA site that would be helpful I think.
 
Back
Top