First headsets were Softcom noise cancelling. Loved them, they were fine...but the noice cancelling circuitry stopped working, and the company is no longer in business. I still may try to repair them sometime. But in the meantime, bought...
Second headset, Pilot USA noise cancelling. They worked. Did not work as well with foggles on, probably because the electronic noise cancelling wasn't all that great. Mid-way through IFR training, when I couldn't hear ATC well and my flight instructor thought I had a hearing problem (or intelligence problem!) we tried switching for a flight. Night and day. So...
Current headset, A30. Way better than the PUSA in pretty much all aspects, as it should be for the cost being higher than some vehicles I've sold. It's also nice because of the bluetooth pairing with the phone. But honestly, if I were just flying VFR and didn't have to listen to the rapid fire NY style ATC stuff, I'd probably still have the PUSA ones. And I'm keeping the PUSA for passenger use. Only drawback for me of A30 is the clunky inline battery holder, but I don't see any viable alternative, and I'd much rather have the weight there than on my head. And I do like that it's regular AA's.