Jim_R
Pattern Altitude
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2010
- Messages
- 1,847
- Display Name
Display name:
Jim
In the thread about the departure procedure for 8S1, a couple of people have made the offhand comment that "you can decline a SID".
Really?
I thought that what you could do is specify "no SIDS/STARs" in the flight plan comments, and that just meant you didn't have published procedures for them onboard, so if ATC chose to assign a departure or arrival procedure, they knew that they'd have to spell it out fix-by-fix, instead of just referring to the procedure title and letting you look it up.
How does one decline a SID? Maybe something like this?
ATC: "Cleared to so-and-so via blah blah blah..."
Pilot: "Mmmm, naaah, I don't like that one. Try again, but without the SID this time, please."
Really?
I thought that what you could do is specify "no SIDS/STARs" in the flight plan comments, and that just meant you didn't have published procedures for them onboard, so if ATC chose to assign a departure or arrival procedure, they knew that they'd have to spell it out fix-by-fix, instead of just referring to the procedure title and letting you look it up.
How does one decline a SID? Maybe something like this?
ATC: "Cleared to so-and-so via blah blah blah..."
Pilot: "Mmmm, naaah, I don't like that one. Try again, but without the SID this time, please."