I see my 182P as a Honda CRV (or RAV 4, take your pick) with wings. It goes just fast enough to do X country (135k + TAS at altitude), can carry wife and all the luggage and never worry about over weight, but can land and take off on just about any field. As there were so many built and are still flying, you'll be able to get parts and keep it flying without drama. For my mission ( flying to fun places as well as local fun flying ) a 172, although a great plane, just wouldn't work.
A few examples. I've got an Angel Flight today; ATL area to Chattanooga to Augusta Burn Center and back. Would be harder to do in a slower, more cramped 172. Given the appointment time, etc., not even sure a 172 could do it. A few weeks ago went up to Chicago for grandchild's 2nd B day. Again, a slower 172 without the "wife luggage capacity" wouldn't have worked for us.
Net net, it comes down to what you want to do with your flying.
Oh, and the TT hours? 5000 isn't even broken in yet.......