There I was...

dtuuri

Final Approach
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
5,215
Location
Madison, OH
Display Name

Display name:
dtuuri
...settling into a nice soft leather chair at the United Airlines Training Center in Denver back in July, 1979. As I looked around at the other eleven new-hire pilots around the conference table doing the same, a feeling of indescribable relief came over me. "I made it," I remember thinking. My life's ambition had been finally realized.
(The recent threads in the medical forum here at POA about the implications of using marijuana caused me to reflect on what I went through to get there, in Denver, so I thought I'd toss it out here for those eager young beavers who'd like to someday fly for a major airline like I did. I wouldn't be surprised if healthy youngsters don't spend much time reading the back and forth about medical issues over in that forum, so here goes.)​

As everyone took turns introducing themselves I found myself wondering how I managed to even make it after all. There were two former captains for Apple Airlines (EDIT: I think these two may have been in a later class after my recall), which had gone out of business. One NASA test pilot. One captain for the fortune 500 company AT&T. One former military pilot who was also a graduate of the United States Air Force Academy. A C-421 corporate chief pilot (and real nice fellow) from Michigan, who's father was an active member of the Flying Physicians Organization and who's mother was the head of the State Department of Aviation in that state. And, well, you get my drift. It was a privilege to be in their company. I, on the other hand, had not even graduated from college. Nor had I been a captain for any company. I was almost too old to have been hired at all.

Until the previous year, sometime in 1978, United had gone for ten full years without hiring a single pilot. Most of the other major airlines were the same. I remember being on a corporate trip to Denver in 1974, as a Learjet copilot, and taking a tour of the very same training center. The tour guide said United hadn't hired a pilot in five years and didn't expect to hire again for another five. My hopes faded and I resigned myself to a life as a corporate pilot.

When the World War II pilots began to retire, word of openings here and there started filtering through the grapevines. No internet back then. Instead, Kip Darby created Future Airline Pilots of America and hopefuls like me sent him $100 for a newsletter every month that ran articles and the latest rumors, airline by airline, from feedback gained by others who managed to land an interview or even be hired. Soon, some of my younger friends with aviation degrees were landing class dates at Southern Airlines, then one at American Airlines. Until that, civilian pilots like us were pretty demoralized because most decent jobs always seemed to go to the ex-military guys--even the corporate jobs. The Viet Nam war produced a lot of pilots who wouldn't have been in the labor pool otherwise, making the competition fierce.

As it turned out, I was rejected by virtually every airline in the country except the very one I always wanted to fly for since I was in junior high school--United Airlines. But getting in the door of their personnel office wasn't any easier than breaking into Ft. Knox. It was a thin line line I walked between being a pest and being persistent. After months of sending in updates and making phone calls, I was finally brought in for employment testing. It was two days at the regional employment office in Cleveland and then another day in Denver for a simulator test and a second medical evaluation including a stress test.

The Stanine Test in Cleveland was quite a thing to experience. Questions like, "What's the aspect ratio of a flying saucer?" And, "What are the ingredients of Chicken Cordon Bleu?" Then there was tracing a pencil around a maze without hitting any of the printed lines and reading instrument presentations of altimeters where the small hands were hidden behind larger ones, etc. The two days capped off with a personal interview with a management pilot from operations in the presence of a Human Resource manager.

The other applicants I met and ate lunch with in Cleveland were military pilots. Sharp looking. Athletic. Articulate. As we ate, I was struck by their naivete toward civil aviation. These guys were impressive in many ways, but not people I'd let fly my plane.

In Denver, the sim session was graded by a computer. The briefing was timed, so every applicant had exactly the same amount of time to study the same flight plan. Each segment of the flight was paused for a second briefing by the IP. Once it was finished, if there were no questions, the IP's lips were sealed until the next segment was completed. There was a written test too, about things like upslope fog and other off-the wall trivia that doesn't usually get a lot of attention.

The sim scores were added to all the other points assessed for everything from college credit and FAA licenses to total time vs age. I can't stress enough that if there were any skeletons in the closet, like drug usage or motor vehicle arrests, they'd have been docked from the totals in some way. The totals of each applicant went into a floating pool for a set period of days. During that period, they would skim the highest scoring applicants from the top, 12 every week when I was in it, for the new-hire classes. At the end of the period, if you weren't picked by then, you were purged.

Some here at POA, most likely those who were never interested in an aviation career, don't seem to distinguish between being "self-rightious" and being driven toward a goal. The competition for these jobs is fierce. You will be lucky if you even get the chance. I knew many good pilots who applied, but didn't make it. Not that that's the end of the world. One friend of mine eventually became the chief pilot for Rockwell. United lost a good one there. So, my point is not to pontificate, but rather to motivate behavior that will enhance your chances of realizing your dream--an airline pilot job.

I didn't stay at United, btw. After being furloughed within the first year I landed a job as chief pilot for a small private company and chose to resign when they called me back. Not the smartest financial decision I ever made, as things turned out, but I can live with it. :)

dtuuri
 
Last edited:
I read you entire post, I'm a little confused by the message you are trying to convey.

You said you got hired at United after a 10 year freeze, with no college degree, no military flying background, no captain experience, and almost too old. Yet you get hired. Answering such questions as, "the ingredients in chicken cordon bleu". Are you suggesting persistence will overcome lack of competitive background?

Then you go on to say how impressive all the other new hires were, but you'd never let them fly your plane. Completely lost me there?

Then you talk about the scoring system. How do you know how things were weighted? You didn't have a degree, didn't have a military background, didn't have command experience, seems like a low score in a lot of categories. So are you suggesting that despite all those things never having smoked a joint made up for that lack of quantifiable background?

So then you realize your dream job, all those years of work paid off, you made it to the show, your lack of any blemish in your background put you over the top. Great story and the happily ever after is…. you quit.

What are we supposed to take from all that?
 
I read you entire post, I'm a little confused by the message you are trying to convey.

You said you got hired at United after a 10 year freeze, with no college degree, no military flying background, no captain experience, and almost too old. Yet you get hired. Answering such questions as, "the ingredients in chicken cordon bleu". Are you suggesting persistence will overcome lack of competitive background?

Then you go on to say how impressive all the other new hires were, but you'd never let them fly your plane. Completely lost me there?

Then you talk about the scoring system. How do you know how things were weighted? You didn't have a degree, didn't have a military background, didn't have command experience, seems like a low score in a lot of categories. So are you suggesting that despite all those things never having smoked a joint made up for that lack of quantifiable background?

So then you realize your dream job, all those years of work paid off, you made it to the show, your lack of any blemish in your background put you over the top. Great story and the happily ever after is…. you quit.

What are we supposed to take from all that?

It's the net points. I had some good ones, but I'm too modest to mention them.

As to the guys I ate lunch with during the first phase of testing--I never saw them again. They apparently didn't make it or got hired someplace else. Or maybe long afterward. :dunno:

dtuuri
 
Last edited:
It's the net points. I had some good ones, but I'm too modest to mention them.

dtuuri

What? Come on.

Was it that you were so damn good looking they had to hire you?

Seriously, many of us have spend a lot of time reading your post, finish the story.
 
What? Come on.

Was it that you were so damn good looking they had to hire you?

Seriously, many of us have spend a lot of time reading your post, finish the story.

I figure he was humble and scored well on the aptitude portions, and the other guys were full of spit and vinegar and didn't.
 
What? Come on.

Was it that you were so damn good looking they had to hire you?

Seriously, many of us have spend a lot of time reading your post, finish the story.

Ok, it could help someone I suppose.

I had been flying since I was 15. Soloed on my sixteenth birthday. I had four years of military experience as an enlisted man--an aircraft mechanic. Good record there. Without a degree, I had my non-traditional life experience evaluated by Thomas Edison College in NJ. That experience included the results of equivalence testing, the "CLEP", done while in the Air Force. I did quite well on that battery compared to the norms of two-year college students. I had an excellent work history, working as a pilot for three different Learjet operators, including EJA (forerunner of Netjets) and a Fortune 500 company. I had a Learjet type rating by then and well over 3000 hours, 2000 giving flight instruction. Like another pilot from that company who was hired by United before me, a military-trained one, I also had a letter of recommendation from our CEO who was a frequent passenger--and who was a member of the board of directors at United. I had an A&P license, too, just like another United pilot I met who was hired before me. The flight engineer written passed with a high score. An ATP license. Maybe more?

All these things, letters of recommendation, college credit, military experience, total time, type ratings, age vs experience went into some kind of algorithm that spit out a number. The process was quite objective.

Not totally objective. During the interview I was asked to recite the memory items from a certain emergency procedure for the Learjet. Also, they asked me if I ever had to take command from a Captain, ie, assert myself rather than go along. I had, in fact, had such an experience that saved our lives. I think it helped me tremendously when I told the story. I'll never know for sure, though. You see, this was not long after United's Portland crash where a DC-8 ran out of gas while preparing the cabin for a possible landing gear failure. A more assertive crew would have intervened and those knowing the inside story, like the management pilot doing my interview, I suspect didn't want any more of those kind of people on the payroll.

You need every edge you can get to survive the process. There's no room for demerits. At least, that's been my experience.

dtuuri
 
Ok, it could help someone I suppose.

I had been flying since I was 15. Soloed on my sixteenth birthday. I had four years of military experience as an enlisted man--an aircraft mechanic. Good record there. Without a degree, I had my non-traditional life experience evaluated by Thomas Edison College in NJ. That experience included the results of equivalence testing, the "CLEP", done while in the Air Force. I did quite well on that battery compared to the norms of two-year college students. I had an excellent work history, working as a pilot for three different Learjet operators, including EJA (forerunner of Netjets) and a Fortune 500 company. I had a Learjet type rating by then and well over 3000 hours, 2000 giving flight instruction. Like another pilot from that company who was hired by United before me, a military-trained one, I also had a letter of recommendation from our CEO who was a frequent passenger--and who was a member of the board of directors at United. I had an A&P license, too, just like another United pilot I met who was hired before me. The flight engineer written passed with a high score. An ATP license. Maybe more?

All these things, letters of recommendation, college credit, military experience, total time, type ratings, age vs experience went into some kind of algorithm that spit out a number. The process was quite objective.

Not totally objective. During the interview I was asked to recite the memory items from a certain emergency procedure for the Learjet. Also, they asked me if I ever had to take command from a Captain, ie, assert myself rather than go along. I had, in fact, had such an experience that saved our lives. I think it helped me tremendously when I told the story. I'll never know for sure, though. You see, this was not long after United's Portland crash where a DC-8 ran out of gas while preparing the cabin for a possible landing gear failure. A more assertive crew would have intervened and those knowing the inside story, like the management pilot doing my interview, I suspect didn't want any more of those kind of people on the payroll.

You need every edge you can get to survive the process. There's no room for demerits. At least, that's been my experience.

dtuuri

OK, thanks, makes more sense.

In my experience having a letter of recommendation from a member of the hiring companies board is probably a lot more important than any of it including the demerits, but I digress.

So why did you quit?
 
Yeah, how can people gain anything in understanding the process if you don't tell us what points in your favor helped get you hired? Fess up, we promise not to call you a braggart.

EDIT: Thanks for the additional information!
 
I read the first post (thanks!) and I got it.

It's a super-competitive business out there. Anything that's a mark against you, for whatever reason, puts you behind anyone without that mark. A decision now (good or bad) can have an affect later.

One of my many CFIs over the years (retired AF and airline) told me about how he lost out on a job at TWA. He was in Kansas City for an interview, and had Mexican for dinner the night before. All was well until it was time for his medical, and that was about the time he started wishing he hadn't had Mexican the previous night. The TWA doc failed him, "Hmm, listening to your gut right now tells me you are having trouble handling the stress of this interview. If you react like this for a simple interview, how can we expect you to react on a trans-Atlantic flight?" "But doc, it's not stress! It's Mexican!" But the doc's decision was final. (He ended up at Frontier instead.)

So, don't eat Mexican before an interview, and don't do drugs.
 
OK, thanks, makes more sense.

In my experience having a letter of recommendation from a member of the hiring companies board is probably a lot more important than any of it including the demerits, but I digress.

So why did you quit?
I'm sure the letter didn't hurt. But then, everybody had them from somewhere. I was lucky enough to have one from a director. I was always impressed by the impartial process at United. We would compare our experiences and all of us agreed that United was far and away the most fair compared to the rest.

I resigned because during my furlough, after a looong spell of unemployment I landed a job flying a Turbo Commander 690B as Chief Pilot. The family that owned the company that owned the plane was super nice to work for. They then bought a Citation II and I loved being able to "do things my way", finally, after a long time of following somebody else's ideas. So, when United called me back, I delayed by taking a two year leave of absence. That got me past a nasty strike too. After two years, I had to return, which I did. But I had got my boss to agree to allow me to continue to manage the flight department and still fly for United. Things were really looking up then! I figured after refresher training I could bid weekend trips and start a management company for corporate aircraft on the side.

My boss reneged on the deal, though. When I came home from Denver he told me he was now more comfortable with my copilot running the department, so gave me an ultimatum: United or him. I wasn't thrilled with the poisonous atmosphere on United's campus in the post strike days. Sitting on the same crew bus with me to and from the Cherry Creek Inn, United's hotel for crewmembers in training, were former picket line-crossers (scabs) and ALPA pilots who hated them. It left a sour taste in my mouth, so when I had to choose, I chose to resign. But it was the toughest decision in my whole life.

United didn't want to hear that though. Nor ALPA. The very next day, I got a call from an ALPA rep who lived in my own neighborhood. Asked me what the problem was. Could he help me somehow? Begged me to change my mind. I invited him along on a little trip to Pinehurst the next weekend and then gave him a little stick time in the Citation on the dead leg home. After meeting my passengers and enjoying the freedom only a corporate jet can offer, he understood.

Management wasn't as easy to convince. They gave me a month off to take care of personal problems (there weren't any). Then brought me First Class to Chicago for a meeting with my supervisor. They were real nice about it, but couldn't believe I was doing it. They gave me a green form documenting my separation from the company, which I've saved to this day. There's a section with a check mark in a box next to "Recommend to rehire" which is the only proof I have that it was my choice to separate, not United's.

dtuuri
 
Opinions vary, but I consider major airlines or the military the only real jobs in aviation. What I mean is that they offer benefits, retirement, paid vacation, etc. along with a living wage. Part 91 is great until the owner decides flying is too expensive, or they just don't like you anymore, or ???. Perhaps some of the large. fractionals like Netjets are good as well I don't know. If I could advise a young person today, I'd say go in the military and get at least your 20, then whatever you do is gravy. There are no 42 year old retires anywhere else.

Sounds like you're happy with your decisions and that's all that matters.
 
Opinions vary, but I consider major airlines or the military the only real jobs in aviation.
Airlines go belly up too, Eastern, National, Pan Am, etc. Military flying can be hazardous to your health. Fractional flying involves living out of your suitcase a week at a time. BTDT, no thanks.
Sounds like you're happy with your decisions and that's all that matters.
I had a good run. Besides, I didn't like United's cap. Made me feel like a pencil with a nickel balanced on top. :)

dtuuri
 
I wouldn't say airlines and military are the only real jobs in aviation. On the RW side of the house there are plenty of contract and DOD jobs that have good pay and benefits as well. A lot of my friends who got out of the military and rolled right into making more money in contract overseas or various DOD positions here.
 
I wouldn't say airlines and military are the only real jobs in aviation. On the RW side of the house there are plenty of contract and DOD jobs that have good pay and benefits as well. A lot of my friends who got out of the military and rolled right into making more money in contract overseas or various DOD positions here.

Sure, but will that last? All I'm saying is a paycheck, medical, base privileges, etc. from your early 40's on is impossible to match. Young guys always want to get out and grab the big dollars, hang out with some guys that have BOTH military and airline retirements and it'll make you envious.
 
Sure, but will that last? All I'm saying is a paycheck, medical, base privileges, etc. from your early 40's on is impossible to match. Young guys always want to get out and grab the big dollars, hang out with some guys that have BOTH military and airline retirements and it'll make you envious.

Well I'm not a DOD / contract fan but most sound pretty secure to me. I've got friends flying FBI, CIA, DOD instructors and some flying in various contractors in the Middle East. None have been laid off yet.

Don't know how stable the airline route is these days but I know in years past they had plenty of furloughs. Guys spend their whole careers in an airline only to get furloughed and later hired back with less benefits / seniority. Of course these days with the drawn downs in the military, it's not as secure as it used to be either.
 
Thanks for posting this. It's a great read.

To the comment about airlines and military being the only options, I think making $140k+ with bonus, benefits, 401k match as a part 91/135 pilot a pretty good deal.
 
To the comment about airlines and military being the only options, I think making $140k+ with bonus, benefits, 401k match as a part 91/135 pilot a pretty good deal.


I make along the same amount flying air ambulance, pt 91/135. I am home every night, the quality of life is great, and I have only been with one company for the last 10 years. When I was with an airline, I didn't have a home, or a life, or even a bank account.
 
Last edited:
My first flight instructor said I have two options with flying. Make it your living and mostly starve or keep it as a hobby and find something else to do for a living.
 
Guys, I am not trying to put down, part 91, DOD, or any other pilot job. I know a lot of you guys make a good living and are happy and that's great.

I'm saying do the math for a person just getting out of high school that wants to fly for a living: A person that retires after 20 years as an O-5 today gets about $2500 a month, plus medical, etc. CONSERVATIVELY lets value all of it at $3000 a month or $36K a year. This goes up 3% for cola every year. To earn that in a safe investment, with the COLA and increases in Medical cost, you would need about $1M. This is at 42 years old.

Also, assuming the academy or ROTC, your college is paid for. While on active duty you're having a great time, housing paid, money, etc. and you're flying military aircraft not some clapped out 152. You're also not trying to start a career starving as a flight instructor for 5 years and racking up $100K in debt.

Once retired you can start a second career with a kick butt resume. Probably go straight to the airlines/Fedex/UPS and start working on number two. IF they go bankrupt or whatever, you still have a fall back.

That was all I was trying to say. Can anyone offer a path as lucrative outside of that?
 
Opinions vary, but I consider major airlines or the military the only real jobs in aviation. What I mean is that they offer benefits, retirement, paid vacation, etc. along with a living wage. Part 91 is great until the owner decides flying is too expensive, or they just don't like you anymore, or ???. Perhaps some of the large. fractionals like Netjets are good as well I don't know.

Guys, I am not trying to put down, part 91, DOD, or any other pilot job. I know a lot of you guys make a good living and are happy and that's great.

I'm saying do the math for a person just getting out of high school that wants to fly for a living: A person that retires after 20 years as an O-5 today gets about $2500 a month, plus medical, etc. CONSERVATIVELY lets value all of it at $3000 a month or $36K a year. This goes up 3% for cola every year. To earn that in a safe investment, with the COLA and increases in Medical cost, you would need about $1M. This is at 42 years old.

Also, assuming the academy or ROTC, your college is paid for. While on active duty you're having a great time, housing paid, money, etc. and you're flying military aircraft not some clapped out 152. You're also not trying to start a career starving as a flight instructor for 5 years and racking up $100K in debt.

Once retired you can start a second career with a kick butt resume. Probably go straight to the airlines/Fedex/UPS and start working on number two. IF they go bankrupt or whatever, you still have a fall back.

That was all I was trying to say. Can anyone offer a path as lucrative outside of that?

You said "airlines or the military" are "the only real jobs in aviation."

Your idea of going to the military until full retirement eligibility there and then going to the airlines is a good one, but that's far from what you said. What would be significantly different about doing your 20 years in the military and then retiring to one of the $140K part 91 or 135 jobs that a couple of posters mentioned they have? :dunno:

And what do you define as a "real" job anyway? I'd take a $140K GA job with home-every-night in a heartbeat.
 
Guys, I am not trying to put down, part 91, DOD, or any other pilot job. I know a lot of you guys make a good living and are happy and that's great.

I'm saying do the math for a person just getting out of high school that wants to fly for a living: A person that retires after 20 years as an O-5 today gets about $2500 a month, plus medical, etc. CONSERVATIVELY lets value all of it at $3000 a month or $36K a year. This goes up 3% for cola every year. To earn that in a safe investment, with the COLA and increases in Medical cost, you would need about $1M. This is at 42 years old.

Also, assuming the academy or ROTC, your college is paid for. While on active duty you're having a great time, housing paid, money, etc. and you're flying military aircraft not some clapped out 152. You're also not trying to start a career starving as a flight instructor for 5 years and racking up $100K in debt.

Once retired you can start a second career with a kick butt resume. Probably go straight to the airlines/Fedex/UPS and start working on number two. IF they go bankrupt or whatever, you still have a fall back.

That was all I was trying to say. Can anyone offer a path as lucrative outside of that?

Well those reasons are why I took that path but it's not as easy as it sounds. Plenty of sacrifices on the military route that many don't want to put up with. We've talked about the AF within the last year no being able to keep pilots. 35AOA was just commenting the other day how they can't keep people. I know people in the Army who can't wait to get out after their 6 yr obligation. Some (OH-58) are getting forced out. So while the military sounds good on paper, I'd say only 1/3 of us who start out in the military stay until retirement.

My point is, you don't even have to stay until retirement to do a "real job." Plenty of DOD FW and RW positions available. You've got CBP, FBI, CIA and a myriad of contract flying jobs. I was reading comments recently from people who didn't even know we have a State Dept flight program. I have friends flying in each of those segments, serving all over the world and making way more than my former military pay and light years above my HEMS pay. I suppose there's a chance of layoffs but no more than any other segment of aviation.

So yeah, I agree with you that the military and the airlines have decent pay and benefits. Just saying there are plenty of other sectors that offer the same.
 
You said "airlines or the military" are "the only real jobs in aviation."

Your idea of going to the military until full retirement eligibility there and then going to the airlines is a good one, but that's far from what you said. What would be significantly different about doing your 20 years in the military and then retiring to one of the $140K part 91 or 135 jobs that a couple of posters mentioned they have? :dunno:

And what do you define as a "real" job anyway? I'd take a $140K GA job with home-every-night in a heartbeat.

I'm suggesting that a real job offers some security, real retirement, etc. not just a paycheck.

What happens if you lose your ticket or medical on a contract job or most part 91/135 jobs? You are out, your career is over, and you start again doing something else at beginning salary. The military can move you to a non-flying job, government can as well, airlines typically have loss of license insurance options also.

Let's look at two options for retirement:

Let's say you fly professionally from 30 to 65 contributing a $1000 a month. That's a pretty high percentage of take home even with a $140K salary. You never take any out, and never miss a payment. You're never unemployed. Of course you never lose your license or medical. You'll have about $1M at 65.

Let's say someone contributes $1000 a month only during their active duty until 42. Then they retire from the military. They don't do anything buy lay on the beach from 42-65 living off their military pension. When they really retire. At 65 they will have $1M in cash, their military retirement check, medical, etc.

I could do one for the airlines, which are also very attractive as long as the airline stays in business. Of course if they don't there might be some help from the PBGC
 
Reminds me of the song "well there I was, the STAR of a Hollywood Movie... far out"
 
Reminds me of the song "well there I was, the STAR of a Hollywood Movie... far out"
Everyone's life is a moving picture. The point of this thread is: If you want it to have a happy ending, don't smoke dope (or get arrested or dishonorably discharged or fired from a job or etc., etc., etc.)!

dtuuri
 
Interesting subject, thanks to all that have contributed.

I do make a good living flying pt 135/91, and I do have a good retirement. Not from any company I've worked for but from my own doing. I did one enlistment in the army when I was young so I have those benefits. I spent about 7 months in a regional airline and left because I had no life, no home, no bank account and no future. After 16 years flying pt 135 I now have a very good portfolio and good investments. I own rental properties and that income currently matches my flying income. A couple of partners and myself are starting an air ambulance company that should be in the air by the end of August. I dont plan on retiring with just 1 million cash. I plan on retiring with 10 times that amount. And I will have done it without depending on a military or an airline career, which both used to be good career paths at one time.

I do have a college degree. I went part time for 8 years, the biggest waste of my time. (I wont tell your kids that if you dont want me to)

Profesional pilot definition of cockpit: A place where pilots gather to talk about their investments and stock options. :lol:

Old soldiers never die, they just fade away.
Old sailors never die, they just sail away.
Old pilots never die, they just collect their pay. ;)
 
Interesting subject, thanks to all that have contributed.

I do make a good living flying pt 135/91, and I do have a good retirement. Not from any company I've worked for but from my own doing. I did one enlistment in the army when I was young so I have those benefits. I spent about 7 months in a regional airline and left because I had no life, no home, no bank account and no future. After 16 years flying pt 135 I now have a very good portfolio and good investments. I own rental properties and that income currently matches my flying income. A couple of partners and myself are starting an air ambulance company that should be in the air by the end of August. I dont plan on retiring with just 1 million cash. I plan on retiring with 10 times that amount. And I will have done it without depending on a military or an airline career, which both used to be good career paths at one time.

I do have a college degree. I went part time for 8 years, the biggest waste of my time. (I wont tell your kids that if you dont want me to)

Profesional pilot definition of cockpit: A place where pilots gather to talk about their investments and stock options. :lol:

Old soldiers never die, they just fade away.
Old sailors never die, they just sail away.
Old pilots never die, they just collect their pay. ;)

Good for you. Nothing as sure as making your own retirement. Hopefully you will encourage others.
 
My Uncle got hired by United, with virtually no prior experience. And the day after he got hired he had a birthday which would put him over the hiring age. he flew DC3s from ATL to Baltimore as FO. He stuck with it through thick and thin. and retired in c1999, from making the CHI-LON run once a month.
+1 on the military retirement thing. You can get in 20 years, and retire with a Captians pay at 40. I'm still kickin' myself in the ass for not joining up straight outta highschool. I'd have been retired for about 16 years now.
HS roomemate is same age, retired MSG, and working on base as DOD civilian in the same job. His retirement income is about double what I make, plus the benefits, and then on top of that he's got the extra income of his civilian job.
My nephew is AF CPT, was flying C17s, and now is flying UAVs, with the option to go back to flying real airplanes when he gets bored. He's got about 8 more years to get in his 20. His brother is mx instructor on F15 also in AF, with about 10 to go.
These kids will retire ~40 or so, and have what it takes to continue in the aviation industry if they choose to do so. Personally, I wouldn't blame them if they chose to not work again. After all they've both served several tours at the front.
 
I'm suggesting that a real job offers some security, real retirement, etc. not just a paycheck.

What happens if you lose your ticket or medical on a contract job or most part 91/135 jobs? You are out, your career is over, and you start again doing something else at beginning salary. The military can move you to a non-flying job, government can as well, airlines typically have loss of license insurance options also.

Let's look at two options for retirement:

Let's say you fly professionally from 30 to 65 contributing a $1000 a month. That's a pretty high percentage of take home even with a $140K salary. You never take any out, and never miss a payment. You're never unemployed. Of course you never lose your license or medical. You'll have about $1M at 65.

Let's say someone contributes $1000 a month only during their active duty until 42. Then they retire from the military. They don't do anything buy lay on the beach from 42-65 living off their military pension. When they really retire. At 65 they will have $1M in cash, their military retirement check, medical, etc.

I could do one for the airlines, which are also very attractive as long as the airline stays in business. Of course if they don't there might be some help from the PBGC

How many enlisted soldiers can save $1k a month?

Your analysis works in any career field, not just the military. Yes, the military allows earlier retirement, and corresponding monthly financial benefits, however, this can be done anywhere, if you have the drive and desire.

To do this, you'd have to be a single military guy, or live a very basic military lifestyle and I think if you talk to today's military families, most would tell you they already do that and can't save $1k per month.

There is a reason that mid to late 40's and 50's are the highest earning potential years. It takes that long to get career experience, and to prepare your life to save significant monies.

I love Dave Ramsey too, but the majority of people will not live the way he talks about.
 
How many enlisted soldiers can save $1k a month?

Your analysis works in any career field, not just the military. Yes, the military allows earlier retirement, and corresponding monthly financial benefits, however, this can be done anywhere, if you have the drive and desire.

To do this, you'd have to be a single military guy, or live a very basic military lifestyle and I think if you talk to today's military families, most would tell you they already do that and can't save $1k per month.

There is a reason that mid to late 40's and 50's are the highest earning potential years. It takes that long to get career experience, and to prepare your life to save significant monies.

I love Dave Ramsey too, but the majority of people will not live the way he talks about.

I'm talking about going in as a 0-1 after ROTC or the academy. Live in the BOQ and you should be able to save $1K a month. As you gain rank you earn more, the amount stays the same. Should be doable.

I saved a lot of money in the military. It isn't that hard when you get free housing and basically free food.
 
I'm talking about going in as a 0-1 after ROTC or the academy. Live in the BOQ and you should be able to save $1K a month. As you gain rank you earn more, the amount stays the same. Should be doable.

I saved a lot of money in the military. It isn't that hard when you get free housing and basically free food.

You could actually save more buy getting a cheap apartment. The amount BAH pays for would allow a good chunk of change left over at the end of the month. Then of course if you deploy, put all your stuff in storage and make all the BAH minus the storage fees. Or you could get lucky like I got. Spend 3.5 years in Germany at the BOQ getting paid a reduced COLA and finding out during out processing that the govt owes you 13 grand. It was like having a savings plan and not even realizing it.
 
I'm suggesting that a real job offers some security, real retirement, etc. not just a paycheck.

What happens if you lose your ticket or medical on a contract job or most part 91/135 jobs? You are out, your career is over, and you start again doing something else at beginning salary. The military can move you to a non-flying job, government can as well, airlines typically have loss of license insurance options also.

I have seen private loss-of-medical/certificate insurance plans for 91/135 pilots advertised in various aviation rags too. So, that gives you at least as much in the way of security as the airlines.

Also, I'm sure there are plenty of 91/135 pilots with a "real retirement." It's just like the rest of the working world, some companies will offer a good 401k plan, some won't, and you just pick the job you want and take care of the retirement yourself.
 
I'm talking about going in as a 0-1 after ROTC or the academy. Live in the BOQ and you should be able to save $1K a month. As you gain rank you earn more, the amount stays the same. Should be doable.

I saved a lot of money in the military. It isn't that hard when you get free housing and basically free food.

Obviously I don't know what your experience in the military was, it seems like it was pretty good. However, I think you're discounting some significant "cons" to the military:

- You can get shot at. Killed. Injured. Disabled.
- Away from home a lot, living in tents etc. in not-so-great places.
- Away from home a lot, hard to raise a family and be there for them.
- Staying in to retirement isn't guaranteed, especially recently. I had a friend who was a Major with about 15 years in, good record, all of a sudden they just told him he was no longer needed due to force reductions. No retirement for him!

Not saying the military is a bad choice, necessarily, but for some people (such as me), the retirement benefits weren't worth it (for me it the was the family life and seeing my daughter grow up in person versus in pictures or on Skype). Though the benefits are worth it for many people, and I appreciate their willingness to stay in, and earn those benefits. But it isn't all the roses that your purely economic evaluation makes it seem. Those benefits do need to be earned, and "earned" in occassionally the hardest sense of the word.
 
Last edited:
Obviously I don't know what your experience in the military was, it seems like it was pretty good. However, I think you're discounting some significant "cons" to the military:

- You can get shot at. Killed. Injured. Disabled.
- Away from home a lot, living in tents etc. in not-so-great places.
- Away from home a lot, hard to raise a family and be there for them.
- Staying in to retirement isn't guaranteed, especially recently. I had a friend who was a Major with about 15 years in, good record, all of a sudden they just told him he was no longer needed due to force reductions. No retirement for him!

Not saying the military is a bad choice, necessarily, but for some people (such as me), the retirement benefits weren't worth it (for me it the was the family life and seeing my daughter grow up in person versus in pictures or on Skype). Though the benefits are worth it for many people, and I appreciate their willingness to stay in, and earn those benefits. But it isn't all the roses that your purely economic evaluation makes it seem. Those benefits do need to be earned, and "earned" in occassionally the hardest sense of the word.

I can't disagree with anything in your post. I also agree everything has a down side. Someone could also just go into the guard and get most of what I mentioned. All I'm saying is, do the math, weight the pros and cons, it's more complicated than just a paycheck.
 
Back
Top