Thank you so much for the input.
The 337s are rather intriguing but the low prices did put up a red warning flag but I wanted some 2nd opinions thinking that the unusual looks might be the low price factor.
My search journey went from Lance to Saratoga to finally thinking a 1979 Cherokee 6 might be the ticket. I prefer the shorter takeoff/landing, higher ceiling, better fuel economy and higher useful load of the 6, are there any counterpoints in favor of the other 2 that I am missing?
The other options are a cirrus SR22/20 or a Socata TB20. Perhaps more fun to fly when just solo/couple 60% of the time. However, these would be a tight squeeze for the whole family and our large dog. Also, I have a hard time imagining grandma etc.climbing up on the wing for egress.
FYI, the only planes for rent in my town are 172s so buying a 4 seater and renting a 6 seater only when needed is not really an option. Mooney and bos are just to tight for me, 6’4" 200lbs.