Lear 60 Boca Raton FL 11/1/26

I thought the audio was the ATC side of it; as soon as I heard the pilot's voice I turned it off. I'm glad there are others made of sterner stuff who can listen and hopefully learn something useful for the rest of us (@hindsight2020) but I'm not on that list, not ashamed to say so.

What a nightmare for all involved.
 
I can't imagine a high speed lawn dart if the HS was gone. Usually, that turns into a hard, hard pitch down that breaks the wings.
1793576031316.png
I wonder if the tail departed in the higher than Vne dive, or the tail departure caused the dive…?
 
but was she part of a two-person crew? Almost sounded like they were trying to work on the issue as she was narrating.
yes...of course she was part of a crew. That just wasn't the focus, nor interest of my post.

Occupational hazard of this so-called "format". Don't read more into it. This peanut gallery just runs out of attention span on me if I write in big boy (supra-120 character) sentences and try to cover all bases. I promise I won't peddle my substack on here when I retire. :fingerwag:

At any rate, it ought to be self-evident that absence of commentary about the other crewmember isn't to mean I don't acknowlege his existence, the equal value of his life, or his role/contribution to the recovery attempt. I'm merely positing that her narration is more important to me because it's almost always absent on accident sequences. When present, it is very useful/elucidating to the safety/lessons learned angle without having to wait on the gatekeepers at the NTSB to describe the water for me, 2 years too late to be of use. That's all.

Again, condolences to all the affected families.
 
It's really a shame that some piece of excrement had to rush and get that ATC recording and immediately post it on social media. No thoughts whatsoever for the victims, only wanting to bask in their few minutes of glory on social media.

I'm sure the youtube "investigators" are also scurrying to get the first post up to tell the unwashed what just happened.

Leaches.
Damn near every rule in aviation came about because someone died. This crash will be no different. RIP to the victims.
 
I listened to it once (wish I hadn’t) and won’t again, but was she part of a two-person crew? Almost sounded like they were trying to work on the issue as she was narrating.
If operating as Part 135, which is very likely with 9 people on board, there would have been a two man crew mandated for the flight. I'm guessing the female was handling radio while someone else was flying.
 
The difference is in those who are using this or any tragedy for promotion. It's pure excrement to post or even repost that recording.
Promotion of what? ATC communications are public by the way, anyone can access those. CVP recordings are different.
 
It is a bit of a coincidence (Avenger system was just deployed there), but you ain't gonna launch in the middle of an urban area without thousands of people hearing it......

Ron Wanttaja
As an aside, I’d be surprised if there weren’t SAMs/MANPADS that accompany the President for years now, and for whatever reason they just made it public.
 
It's really a shame that some piece of excrement had to rush and get that ATC recording and immediately post it on social media. No thoughts whatsoever for the victims, only wanting to bask in their few minutes of glory on social media.

I'm sure the youtube "investigators" are also scurrying to get the first post up to tell the unwashed what just happened.

Leaches
I have a friend, a girl, who flies a Lear 60 and I can’t get in touch with her. Hoping she’s safe and terrified that she’s not. People don’t think, or care, about how this affects the friends and families. Maybe time to leave social media.

Edit… I heard from my friend, not her. I feel so bad for the families who lost loved ones today and pray the girl’s family never hears that audio.
 
Last edited:
yes...of course she was part of a crew. That just wasn't the focus, nor interest of my post.

Occupational hazard of this so-called "format". Don't read more into it. This peanut gallery just runs out of attention span on me if I write in big boy (supra-120 character) sentences and try to cover all bases. I promise I won't peddle my substack on here when I retire. :fingerwag:

At any rate, it ought to be self-evident that absence of commentary about the other crewmember isn't to mean I don't acknowlege his existence, the equal value of his life, or his role/contribution to the recovery attempt. I'm merely positing that her narration is more important to me because it's almost always absent on accident sequences. When present, it is very useful/elucidating to the safety/lessons learned angle without having to wait on the gatekeepers at the NTSB to describe the water for me, 2 years too late to be of use. That's all.

Again, condolences to all the affected families.
Ugh. I was simply trying to distinguish between whether or not she was presumed to be the one at the controls or narrating as she observed someone else’s struggle to reestablish control. There were some subtle cues that indicated the latter. My observation wasn’t intended as questioning your line of thought as it was clarifying what I heard without having to hear it again. It’s bad enough to have heard it once, yet somehow knowing she was PM makes the perspective we heard even worse (also not intended to minimize anyone else on the plane).
 
Thanks for the warning. I will not listen to the audio.

Prayers for the families of those lost. They have joined a terrible club that I would not wish on anyone.
 
As an aside, I’d be surprised if there weren’t SAMs/MANPADS that accompany the President for years now, and for whatever reason they just made it public.
During Trump's first term I landed at MMU once when he was at Bedminster and saw an Avenger parked in the grass near the windsock.
 
Ugh. I was simply trying to distinguish between whether or not she was presumed to be the one at the controls or narrating as she observed someone else’s struggle to reestablish control. There were some subtle cues that indicated the latter. My observation wasn’t intended as questioning your line of thought as it was clarifying what I heard without having to hear it again. It’s bad enough to have heard it once, yet somehow knowing she was PM makes the perspective we heard even worse (also not intended to minimize anyone else on the plane).
Copy all. I apologize for my misunderstanding of your post.
 
For anyone who hasn’t listened to the audio, just don’t. It’s traumatizing. I wish I hadn’t heard it.
I wouldn’t put as traumatizing, and I have listened to many. But I think as pilots we should listen. This is that reality we all face when one little thing can snowball into something bigger, and bigger.
 
RIP. Horrible. A normal day with weather in Florida, ends with the worst possibility. I see the comments about listening to the audio... and posting the audio. I will offer a slightly different take (my opinion). It is horrible to listen to. As someone who works in ATC, it also served as a very good reminder... complacency happens when we don't check ourselves and remind ourselves what the stakes are, and what possible outcomes are in an otherwise routine and calm profession. That audio is the reality of possible outcomes for ATC and of course for flying. I commend the female pilot for staying calm, trying to work the problem... if you are upset by graphic content like that, do not listen to it. For some of us, its ok to be upset by this type of stuff sometimes. I will remember it going to work tomorrow, and for many days to come.

EDIT: I totally condemn the MANY MANY grifters on Youtube using images and quotes in thumbnails and videos for shock, awe, and views. That is truly disgusting. Also, the conspiracy folks have ALREADY started on the "it was a missile heading for Mar A Lago"... before the fire is even out.
 
Last edited:
I mean this with the utmost somberness: her choice and ability (whether purposed or incidental) to transmit her flight parameters condition through that sequence, will be her legacy for those of us still alive to learn from it. She did us all a solid in that regard, in spite of the reflexive recoil most people have to hearing that female shriek upon realization she's about to die. May she rest in peace; I cannot imagine for family members to have to be exposed to hearing their loved one's last frantic clamor. That's how people get legit PTSD; not everybody is built to disassociate the screams of their loved one sufficiently to not get "stuck" post-stress. It's usually why NTSB tends to clip those parts out, as it isn't salient to the safety angle. Digressing.

They will not find much useful in that missile crater. Hope they find the stabs, but I don't think they'll be in the crater. They're prob miles away, dozens away if the stabs broke when she first got the nose-down departure in the 30s. The video is useful, hopefully they can process the rendering to evaluate the absence of the horizontal stabs. All in all, this is extremely important 1st hand account we have. Occam got it from here.

People upthread already beat Occam to it:
1) Continued flight into worsening convective turbulence, worsening precipitation intensity as admitted by the crew, with also admitted difficulty maintaining static altitude (which you shouldn't do that anyways in a turbulent cell) before the control departure event.
2) The cell won: broke their horizontal stabs, the aggressive pitch down departure is textbook aerodynamic response, exactly as she's describing it on the radio.
3)Unrecoverable lawndart, with the vertical speeds to match. The video is not at all suprising. The audio confirms and is physics-compatible for the entire thing start to finish.

The real question here is: what's going on with the decisional aspect of paid flight in these circles? Folks are that job-fearful of saying no? I recognize the employment situation is weak right now, but I rather be unemployed than dead. I know why this happens more in limos than public buses, but for the sake of not being polemic in the same post as I'm offering condolences to the surviving families of the deceased, I'll digress and let the rest of the peanut gallery take it where this thing is going anyways.

Stay safe out there, and please practice saying no without fear in the mirror. Could help you one day.
I too found it remarkable she was able to narrate once at the point of no return. An absolutely terrifying moment and still had enough composure to call out vertical speed and bank angle. I doubt I'd be able to even find the ptt switch.
 
Sincere prayers for those onboard that Lear, and for their loved ones. The fact that all of this is all over the news does not speak well for human decency in our society today.
 
From a friend who sent me this: concerning instant ice buildup.

The aircraft quickly went into an overspeed as a result. I am only a humbled aerodynamicist by trade- in a Lear 60, the overspeed caution is on the threshold of a transonic phenomena called 'Mach Tuck', where the shock wave was progressed far enough aft to overcome control surfaces (with non-transonic airfoils) and cause a dangerous aerodynamic imbalance (a rapid pitch down- how fast & severe is solely based on the wing's coefficient of moment) that can and has led to flight control 'hardovers' and or air vehicle breakup.
 
This one will give you nightmares.
Lear 60 crash.

The live ATC is not something you want to hear if you are squeamish.
R.I.P
Sad indeed.

Also, there is a master thread on this crash here (just to prevent duplicates)
 
Since we're throwing things against a wall already... Coffin corner?
 
It was clearly a high altitude “event”.

The non chalant climb might be a clue. Also the turbulence. “Precip”. No matter, your margins are small up there. Can’t go faster, can’t go slower. Turbulence reduces your stall margin. Lots of stuff. It takes a bit to really understand it and be able to apply it when things go off script up there.

The event seems to immediately result in an upset and then it’s likely all over.

My guess is she was calling out altitude as I doubt anything reads up to 20k fpm… never seen a vsi indicate more than six thousand. Again, not really relevant.

Horrifying…
 
Will be interesting learning how much lightning was popping in that storm cluster. Any thunderstorm can kill you, however I've never really considered Florida home to the monsters like those that plague Texas and the plains states.

It appears the cell that caused the upset and LOC was isolated from the main batch, and in the building stage. Researchers in armored T-28's who get paid to fly through them have reported that the building ones are often the most violent, even before they begin sparking lightning.

The lightning strike website I use is down right now. If and when it returns I'll like to see what the Lear mixed with or circumvented in that region, and especially the electrical history of that isolated cell.
 
After hearing part of the audio before turning it off as it escalated I was reminded of a question I have always had with aviation accidents...and I don't mean this as a d!@k but I always truly wondered how many fatal crashes are ultimately a result of pilot incapacitation due to being overwhelmed with fear and/or emotion leading to poorer ADM once the emergency situation begins vs those that are able to recover a more favorable outcome...and I don't mean poor ADM that put them in the situation but rather once they are in an emergency.

I'm not going to pretend I know what it is like being in the cockpit at that moment but I have been right in the middle of a mass casualty event with bullets flying and fatalities and witnessed first hand both ends of the spectrum from folks that enter hyper focused hero mode and others physically paralyzed with fear and know that pilots are also just people.

Now I get of your wing falls off there is only so much you can do but I always do still have that question in general when it comes to aviation accidents.

And no, don't listen to that audio.
 
Last edited:
After hearing part of the audio before turning it off as it escalated I was reminded of a question I have always had with aviation accidents...and I don't mean this as a d!@k but I always truly wondered how many fatal crashes are ultimately a result of pilot incapacitation due to being overwhelmed with fear and/or emotion leading to poorer ADM once the emergency situation begins vs those that are able to recover a more favorable outcome...and I don't mean poor ADM that put them in the situation but rather once they are in an emergency.

I've wondered the same. Especially crashes that follow excited radio chatter when (IMO) a pilot's brain should be super focused on saving their own and everyone else's' bacon in situations where absolutely nobody located on the other end of the radio is going to help them save the day.
 
Since we're throwing things against a wall already... Coffin corner?

Not if they had descended from 430 8 minutes prior as reported by my radar.

 
Last edited:
Back
Top