Yeah, I'd have someone take another look at your exhaust system. My plane was purchased with a relatively recent new exhaust system installed. I noticed that I was feeling unusually fatigued after flying but the little dot on the sticky CO detector looked OK (obviously not a precise instrument!). I happened to purchase a second headset for my wife to use (Lightspeed Delta Zulu) which has a built-in CO detector. It was fine on the ground, but in a climb it started squawking at me about increased CO. Seemed to resolve again in level flight, but it was definitely heading in the direction of triple digits during climbs and slow-flight practice. Turns out that whatever yahoo installed the exhaust system decided to use some non-appropriate sealant. My mechanic figured this out during the first annual and was nearly throwing things in frustration.
The values you're showing are suboptimal but not concerning for incapacitation. Doesn't mean the problem can't get suddenly worse though, so probably worth your while to at least have someone take a close look at the usual suspects.