Fuel planning accident report

poadeleted3

Pattern Altitude
Joined
Mar 2, 2005
Messages
2,055
Pilot plans a 4 hr leg, at 10 gph, with an estimated 45 usable on board. Makes an unplanned stop, doesn't refuel, and continues on that four hour leg. Something about this makes me go ARRRRRRGHH!!! Regs say 1/2 hr fuel is legal for day VFR, but it's cutting it awfully close for my taste under the best of circumstances. It's cutting it waaaay to close if your usable fuel is "estimated." Add an unplanned stop and departure and you get the accident report quoted below:

The pilot stated that he had planned a cross country flight from Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, to Ocala, Florida, with 2 fuel stops along the route. During the flight to the second fuel stop, the engine lost fuel pressure, and the airplane impacted trees during a forced landing on a road. Seven days before the accident flight, the airplane was topped off with fuel, and was flown in the area for about a 15 minute flight. The flight departed at about 0720, they landed at the first fuel stop at about 0920, and refueled the airplane with 20 gallons of fuel. He estimated that he had a total of 45 gallons of usable fuel on board for the flight to the second fuel stop. He stated that he would make a decision after 2 hours into the flight to determine if they would require a stop for fuel before reaching the second fuel stop, at a fuel consumption of 10 gallons per hour. He forecasted the flight to be 4 hours. Twenty minutes into the flight to the second fuel stop, they stopped at the Moore County Airport for a restroom stop, and departed at about 1130. During the engine run-up check for departure, he noted that he failed to reset the timer to monitor the fuel when he departed the first fuel stop. He reset the timer and made a mental note to include approximately 30 minutes extra when figuring the fuel status en route. At about 1530, about 12 miles from the second fuel stop, the pilot noted a loss of fuel pressure. He switched tanks, turned on the fuel pump, enriched the fuel mixture, and about 2 minutes later the fuel pressure was lost again. He advised Jacksonville Approach Control of his intentions to land on a road or in a field. A road was located and he glided the airplane to land. He noticed a gate along the landing path and maneuvered the airplane over the gate. As the airplane came back down, the left wing struck trees resulting in the airplane rotating counter clockwise before coming to a stop. He and the passenger exited the airplane, and called Flight Service to advise the authorities of what had happened. According to the passenger, they departed after 11:15 am from the Moore Airport that day. While en route, at about 3:00 pm, the engine sputtered as if it was running out of fuel. The pilot switched from the left fuel tank to the right fuel tank and mentioned that they had enough fuel for a four hour trip, and that the right tank would be more than enough to get them to the airport. He had been regularly switching tanks during the flight. A few minutes later the engine sputtered again. The pilot said "this can't be happening; we have enough fuel for 4 hours". The engine went on and off and then lost power. The pilot stated to the NTSB and the FAA that he had experienced fuel exhaustion, due to miscalculation of the fuel and there were no mechanical failures or malfunctions to the airplane or any of its systems prior to the accident.
 
At the first fuel stop, they took 20 gallons. Sounds like that is what he ordered vs fill up. My guess is if he really filled up, he might of had his 45 gallons available. Since he probably didn't know how much fuel was on board (he ran out), then he NEVER filled up.
I KNOW what my plane uses for fuel (7g). This is verified with almost each flight and the actual fuel used. In addition to knowing, I use 8 gallons when planning a flight. Useful load is 48 g and I have never left my home airport on half tanks.
Running out of fuel is mostly pilot error. Visual observation plus proper planning will keep you out of that column.
 
i visually check the fuel tanks no matter what..i dont trust guages..especially in the 1980's warrior i rent..even if i filled up before i left home and only flew 30 mins or whatever i would visually check the fuel again before i took off...just to have peace of mind and to know that i wasnt spewing fuel out during my flight or something crazy like that

Ant
 
SupraPilot said:
and to know that i wasnt spewing fuel out during my flight or something crazy like that

Ant
That's actually one of my checklist items after climbout...visually check the wings for fuel loss (due to loose or missing fuel cap) and ice formation.
 
Fellow and his wife on a long x-c landed at our local airport last week and took on 38.5 gallons. This after making a go-around. Total fuel capacity of his plane is 42.0 gallons, 39 usable. I wonder how many airports they flew over getting to ours.
 
docjohnson said:
That's actually one of my checklist items after climbout...visually check the wings for fuel loss (due to loose or missing fuel cap) and ice formation.
That's the downside to high wing aircraft - it's pretty dang difficult to get a visual on those gas caps!! :dunno:

That said, this guy was apparently insistent on his outcome . . .
 
etsisk said:
That's the downside to high wing aircraft - it's pretty dang difficult to get a visual on those gas caps!! :dunno:

That said, this guy was apparently insistent on his outcome . . .

My instructor made good use of his camera phone for that purpose. Arm out the window, snap one of the closest, then angle and snap another. Worked pretty well. Just don't drop the phone.
 
etsisk said:
That's the downside to high wing aircraft - it's pretty dang difficult to get a visual on those gas caps!! :dunno:
You can see fuel coming out of a high wing aircraft. It looks like white vapor behind the wing.
 
As the price of fuel continues to rise, my bet is we'll see more and more pilots stretching their fuel to get to that next cheap AirNav stop, or buying just "enough" fuel for the return flight because their destination FBO was too expensive.

Greg
182RG
 
Steve said:
Fellow and his wife on a long x-c landed at our local airport last week and took on 38.5 gallons. This after making a go-around. Total fuel capacity of his plane is 42.0 gallons, 39 usable. I wonder how many airports they flew over getting to ours.

the other day i flew the FBO's newer 172sp, checked the tanks visually and it was low (i sorta trust the fuel guages a little better also in that plane) it needed fuel but the pump at my home airport was down for the day so i had to fly it over to another airport which is only about 12nm away for a fill...on the 45 the low fuel warning light started to blink for a bit...it took almost 34 gals total.. i knew i was gonna make it to the airport but that was def the only time i have EVER been that low or had a low fuel light blink while flying..

also..even though u can see the fuel caps in a low wing doesnt mean the little drain valves on the bottom to where u test the fuel isnt pooring fuel out either...

Ant
 
SupraPilot said:
the other day i flew the FBO's newer 172sp, checked the tanks visually and it was low (i sorta trust the fuel guages a little better also in that plane) it needed fuel but the pump at my home airport was down for the day so i had to fly it over to another airport which is only about 12nm away for a fill...on the 45 the low fuel warning light started to blink for a bit...it took almost 34 gals total.. i knew i was gonna make it to the airport but that was def the only time i have EVER been that low or had a low fuel light blink while flying..

also..even though u can see the fuel caps in a low wing doesnt mean the little drain valves on the bottom to where u test the fuel isnt pooring fuel out either...

Ant

If memory serves the newer C172SPs have a capacity of 56 gallons with 52 usuable, so you were not anywhere near low fuel. Probably just the fuel level indicator bouncing around during the turn due to fuel sloshing around.
 
A week ago or so I went flying with my son in the Arrow. Checked the tanks and both were just below the tabs (down 7 gallons each from full). Not good, the planes are supposed to be put away full. Adding insult, the previous pilot forgot to put his name in the log (included the Hobbs and tach times, and destination). So I had to have the FBO come over and fill the tanks before we went to commit an act of aviation. Still had plenty of gas for what I had in mind, but... Took just over 14 gallons to fill the tanks. Guess those tabs are well calibrated. Made sure to fill it up before we put it away. He logged 1.4 hours and should have burned about 10 gph. Guess he did.
 
I've landed at the home airport to find my hangar neighbor's debonair weeping fuel from the wing tank drain in a steady drip, almost stream, with a large puddle under the plane.

SupraPilot said:
also..even though u can see the fuel caps in a low wing doesnt mean the little drain valves on the bottom to where u test the fuel isnt pooring fuel out either...

Ant
 
Back
Top