It would be too rich because it died from fuel starvation (running a tank dry) and switching to the tank with fuel in it. If you know more than the guys who wrote the POH then by all means write to Piper and explain it to them. I'm sure they will issue the POH update shortly and I will wait anxiously by the mailbox for delivery.
Thank you eversomuch for your keen insight and I look forward to any future submissions you may offer. POA is truly a wonderful place with some much knowledge and understanding.
(for the sarcasm impaired, yes this is a sarcastic response to a post which ignores the stated source of an operating caution and pretends to know more than the POH)