Electric Airplanes... No way.

CT4ME

Cleared for Takeoff
Joined
Oct 24, 2011
Messages
1,321
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Display Name
CT4ME
Home Airfield
KDVT
This was lifted from an excellent website that focuses on LSAs and smaller aircraft... ByDanJohnson.com. The dialog comes from Tom Peghiny, an aviation veteran, who is currently exploring ways to get the FAA moving on electric propulsion rules. Right now, the big, bad lithium battery is viewed as a potential safety issue.

INVENTOR: "FAA, I have an idea. I think we might be able to power airplanes with a fluid. It might prove to be very efficient."

FAA: "Oh, what's that? We have to be very careful with new ideas, you know."

INVENTOR: "We'll it's an explosive liquid ... really packs a punch. It could keep aircraft aloft for hours at a time."

FAA: "Explosive! Oh, we don't like the sound of that very much."

INVENTOR: "No, really. This stuff, called gasoline, has a very high energy density, is compact, can be easily loaded onto the aircraft, doesn't cost too much for the energy it delivers ..."

FAA: "Don't try to snow us with all that technobabble. You said 'explosive,' didn't you? We're still trying to wrap our minds around that."

INVENTOR: "Oh, it can be done without much danger. We'll put the fuel in the wings. We'll put a firewall between the engine and the occupants. Fuel lines will be carefully routed around the cockpit."

FAA: "You mean you want to pump an explosive liquid near the occupants, put it into an engine compartment forward of the cockpit, make a spark many times per second, and explode this stuff in cylinders!?"

INVENTOR: "Yeah, I think it can work really well. This gasoline stuff ... sure it's highly flammable, but we can handle it safely."

FAA: "Flammable! Explosive! Sparks to ignite it! All with the occupants downwind of this stuff!?"

INVENTOR: "Yeah, FAA. This gasoline thing is gonna be big. We might even use it automobiles, in lawn mowers, and in children's toys."

FAA: "Hold on, wait a minute, stop right now. I can't see us approving such an energy source for perhaps years. This sounds crazy. Who would possibly think carrying around hundreds of pounds of explosive liquid in a three dimensional environment could be safe. We're going to have to examine this very carefully. It could take decades."

INVENTOR: "Oh, man. I don't think I can stay in business that long.

FAA: "Yeah, well, we have reliable electric-powered airplanes today. We honestly don't know what you are thinking with this half-baked idea to carry gasoline in airplanes. Plus, we're obliged to alert the automobile, lawn mower, and children's toy regulators since you mentioned those products as well.

FAA: (walking away muttering under their breath...) "What on earth will these crackpots come up with next. Really, gasoline on airplanes. That's just nuts. We better form a new department to confront this possibility. What if Mr. Inventor is right and this gasoline-on-airplanes idea should take off. Crazy ..."

INVENTOR: (sighing deeply...) "Dang it! I thought this was such a great idea, but man, convincing these government folks is going to be tough. Whew! Better join LAMA and see if they can help."

OK, that last sentence is tongue-in-cheek, but that's the story. Hope you liked it. I'm still smiling from Tom's sharp-as-a-pin humor.
 
That was paraphrased from an "electric cars are the best thing in the world and all gasoline models should be outlawed" site.
 
So how would one stay night current in a solar powered airplane...??? :dunno: :lol::lol::lol:

Really enjoyed the story.!!
 
Well a Lithium Ion battery isn't exactly solar powered. I don't think the issue of the battery is it's fire potential, it's a energy:weight issue.
 
I read a similar article about using wood to build houses. The point was that today, you could never introduce a construction material that is flammable, prone to insect damage, rots when wet and has no manufacturing standards.
 
When we go to electric airplanes ,are we going to need A+Ps that are licensed electricians?
 
I read a similar article about using wood to build houses. The point was that today, you could never introduce a construction material that is flammable, prone to insect damage, rots when wet and has no manufacturing standards.
I heard the same thing about getting the fda to approve asprin. All things have risks. It's how one mitigates them.
 
When we go to electric airplanes ,are we going to need A+Ps that are licensed electricians?

In a manner of speaking we are already certified aircraft electricians as we work on the aircraft's electrical system. It is part of the program. The additional technology that an A&P would have to learn in order to work on an electric powered airplane is relatively minor in comparison to all of the other things we had to learn.
 
Well if you've purchased any cordless power tools recently that use lithium-ion batteries you might notice that the first 20 page's of the owners manual cover how to recharge your batteries without burning your house down. :rolleyes:
 
Same idea years ago with the idea of replacing clean nuclear power plants with the idea of using messy, smokey, dangerous to mine coal.
 
I believe there's an electric powered Diamond DA20 at KSMQ actually, let me see if I can find some info on it.
 
Back
Top