Big change in FAA Antidepressant Policy: Time reduced from 6 months > 3 months

  • Thread starter Thread starter HIMS AME Rocky Jedick
  • Start date Start date
H

HIMS AME Rocky Jedick

Guest
FAA announced tonight at Grand Rounds that Special Issuance package can be submitted for consideration after only 3 months on stable medicine AND dose! This markedly reduces time needed for a pilot or ATCS to be considered for SI.

To note, there are now 9 CONDITIONALLY acceptable antidepressants for SI.

The FAA continues to move in a direction to reduce stigma and encourage pilots to disclose mental health concerns by reducing barriers to special issuance and down time.
 
But wait, the FAA is backwards, inflexible and not following the science! How could they be updating their rules or guidance allowing greater options and flexibility for airmen with mental health issues… again? I just don’t understand!

/sarcasm
 
Since the oririgna petition (adopted in 2010) when it was a 1 year stable, to 2014 when it was 6 moths stable to 3 month swhich is finally reasonable. Thsi is the ONLY change to bones of the program, however.

The did take pains to say, however that if the psychiatrist's note sez return in on e month, they won't consider that stable. Return in 3 months, allright. Anything less...not so much.

And there is a new HIMS-AME.SSRI checklist to match.
 
Since the oririgna petition (adopted in 2010) when it was a 1 year stable, to 2014 when it was 6 moths stable to 3 month swhich is finally reasonable. Thsi is the ONLY change to bones of the program, however.

The did take pains to say, however that if the psychiatrist's note sez return in on e month, they won't consider that stable. Return in 3 months, allright. Anything less...not so much.

And there is a new HIMS-AME.SSRI checklist to match.
why isn't it valid to say, "come back in a month" as part of the process of establishing stability?
 
why isn't it valid to say, "come back in a month" as part of the process of establishing stability?
Becuase typically psychiatrist space out the appointments when they are happy with stability. Say a pilot is 90 days on the new med and sees the psychiatrist. "Come back next month" is not what they do for stable patients. They do "come back in 6 months".
 
But.... an applicant still has to spend the money for the HIMS what not, cog screens, etc. ? And continue to spend the money for on going HIMS AME evaluations, etc.? Honest question - does anyone really get a medical if they're taking ABCD on a regular basis, even if it's on the approved list? And it will still take years to get the SI? After reading posts, I've formed (maybe the wrong) impression that getting a medical if taking ABCD on a regular basis is the same as getting a medical after a few DUIs.
 
Nobody said cheap nor quick. Just maybe 3 mos. shorter…

Copy that. So maybe "big change" is not quite on the mark. Maybe from 5 years to 4 years and 9 months?

But a tangential question: Do people who apply ever actually get this SI?

2nd Tangent: Depression is a puzzle. Years ago I worked in market research / customer behavior for a company to do anything possible to get clients to engage in health, and one area was mental health. I found through interviews and reviewing the data there was / is a shortage of psychiatrists, especially for senior citizens. There is also the rise of "helpful PCP's" who prescribe anti depressants even though that's not their area of expertise. The good is they're getting help that 50 years ago would be science fiction. The "could be better" would be having more available specialized doctors that could treat even better than your PCP.

On one hand, so much has been done to alleviate this condition with modern drugs it's amazing. Prozac 20 years ago was on the cover of Time magazine. On the other hand they're still not sure what causes it, and although the modern drugs are working, they're now not exactly sure how they work.

One specific area was with those who had surgery where they had to go on by pass. For some unknown reason, the by pass caused a much higher level of a chance of a depression. No one knows why, what exactly is happening with being on by pass causes that.
 
1st tangent- yes, I have ~ a dozen guys - some first class, who are working 121s with this SI in place.
The other items, are really tangential...
 
1st tangent- yes, I have ~ a dozen guys - some first class, who are working 121s with this SI in place.
The other items, are really tangential...
I’ve got a buddy that was at a University going through their Commercial Pilot program, and lost his medical because of anti-depressants. He’s been fighting to get it back… jumped through all the hoops, waited for a response from the FAA, then they sent him the same letter asking for all of the same stuff all over again. They try their hardest to make it as difficult as possible.
 
1st tangent- yes, I have ~ a dozen guys - some first class, who are working 121s with this SI in place.
The other items, are really tangential...
What is the usual time needed? 5 years?
 
Mental health diagnosis and treatment/care is a mess. Improving, but a LONG way to go.
Yeah, there are two main problems. It's mostly impossible to objectively diagnose. It's mostly impossible to objectively treat.

Diagnosis relies mostly on patient reports. Patients who, we must remember, are seeking treatment for mental issues. Not a great situation. Not like sticking someone with a bellyache in a scanner, seeing a tumor and pulling it out.

Treatment relies on knowing what exactly has gone wrong in a particular patient. The major branches being trauma or genetics. Different treatments for each. Genetics should be easier, but as someone who went that that process with a loved one, the state of the art seemed no better than throwing a dart. Got the genetics test, not crazy expensive (at the time, about a mortgage payment), but definitely didn't get filed under the category of budget dust. Test recommended which drugs might be more suitable. Tried a couple of them. One made things a little worse. One made things a lot worse. As kind of a hail mary ended up trying lithium (the drug, not the song on repeat) and it was basically a miracle cure. It was explained at the time that lithium is no longer a go-to treatment because it's got a pretty legit list of side effects and requires ongoing testing ($300 a quarter, IIRC) to make sure it isn't building up in the system, but in our case it was a game changer.
 
Last edited:
@172andyou thanks for sharing that. I’ve got a loved one that has been through the wringer with tests, hospitalizations (1 involuntary), and up to 4 medications at a time during the worst periods. Most recent has been lithium carbonate for the last couple months and is the sole med. This is the most “normality” I’ve seen in the 5 years since diagnosis and treatment - and by normal I don’t mean muted or neutral, I mean how things were, original personality we grew to know and love is coming back, along with logic and reason. I was doubtful and “scared” when I heard lithium was being prescribed and had thoughts of mid-20th century sanitariums…

Again, thanks.
 
I was told lithium was the gold standard for the condition it treats. And when. i compared the side effect profile to other mood stabilizers like Depakote it didn’t seem any worse. Though the narrow therapeutic range can cause some concern
 
I was told lithium was the gold standard for the condition it treats. And when. i compared the side effect profile to other mood stabilizers like Depakote it didn’t seem any worse.
While the side effect list (and length of list) might be similar. They are more likely with lithium. There are definitely docs out there that still think of it as a first line. But that's increasingly not the case, there are lots of alternatives that more effectively treat most patients and as I previously wrote, there is little about this domain that is objective.

Great read here about the pluses and minuses of lithium. As the article points out, it would be game changing if we could get to the point of being able to objectively understand when lithium is going to work. It's shocking (or maybe completely understandable, depending on which side of the bed one got up on this morning) that it's 2025 and we don't know the biomarkers that would indicate for lithium.
 
Last edited:
Heck - we don’t know how it works. Lots of progress, lots more to go.
 
... jumped through all the hoops, waited for a response from the FAA, then they sent him the same letter asking for all of the same stuff all over again. They try their hardest to make it as difficult as possible.

Sounds like the bank when they say, "sure, you can apply for the loan ... "
 
Mental health diagnosis and treatment/care is a mess. Improving, but a LONG way to go.
While I agree with everything you said, I’ll go out on a limb and say, with zero formal data, that mental health issues also constitute the medical category with the greatest risk to passengers.

If the left-seater has a heart attack, stroke, hypoglycemic episode, heat exhaustion, the vapors, or pretty much anything else, the right-seater can land the plane (and has).

By contrast, if either seat decides they need to auger everyone in, they do - and have. The very short list: Air India 171, Malaysia Airlines 370, Germanwings 3525 (unsubstantiated speculation on my part for some of these).

Mental health issues are complex.
 
How does the FAA deal with medications such as Cymbalta issued for diagnosed Nerve Pain (as opposed to Mental Health), or nortriptylene? I realize now they're prescribed for depression - but that's not what they were prescribed for historically in my case.
 
Cymbalta needs the ON SSRI/OnAndepressive protocol.
The only real expense is the neurocog eval after 3 months stable.
Nortryptylene isn't certificable.
 
How does the FAA deal with medications such as Cymbalta issued for diagnosed Nerve Pain (as opposed to Mental Health), or nortriptylene? I realize now they're prescribed for depression - but that's not what they were prescribed for historically in my case.
"Prescribed for historically," as in you're no longer taking them? If that's what you mean, then you should know that you'll need to disclose the diagnosis ("have you ever"), but MedXpress doesn't ask about medications you aren't currently taking.
 
Lindbergh’s correct. Have you been off them?
They gave me Cymbalta after back surgery for nerve paint last year and I discontinued it within 1 week of taking it - wasn't for me.
I was also given nortriptylene for migraines by the VA even though I said I specifically couldn't consume anything that would jeopardize my medical - I guess the neuro wasn't FAA conversant, and I didn't check it before I took it for a week before bedtime. It's been...3-4 months?
 
They gave me Cymbalta after back surgery for nerve paint last year and I discontinued it within 1 week of taking it - wasn't for me.
I was also given nortriptylene for migraines by the VA even though I said I specifically couldn't consume anything that would jeopardize my medical - I guess the neuro wasn't FAA conversant, and I didn't check it before I took it for a week before bedtime. It's been...3-4 months?
So when Medxpress asks if you currently use any medications, answer accordingly. You will need to disclose the back pain and the migraines. The FAA doesn't like migraines, but is you meet certain criteria, they are on the list of conditions that the AME can nevertheless issue you a medical.

Here's the worksheet for that: https://www.faa.gov/ame_guide/media/C-CACIMigraine.pdf

If you decide to proceed with obtaining a medical, first schedule a consult with your AMEI. Not an exam. If your AME will not schedule a consult, or doesn't understand what you're asking for, he is the wrong AME. Go to a different AME.
 
Get a letter from him indicating why they were prescribed and the date that you wnat entered into the record as "discontinuation date".

The CACI migraine sheet, the feds have eviscerated. Just like they did for CACI Psoriatic arthritis. Congress needs to swat them down again.

You'll need an officie visit with the neurologist that indicated frequency, and if the are visual or vascular phonmena with them, and the one time MRI of the brain.

B
 
Back
Top