50 yo Cognac, Brandy or other

Lindberg

Final Approach
Joined
Sep 25, 2013
Messages
9,954
Location
North Texas
Display Name
Lindberg
A good friend is turning 50 and I was thinking to get him some 50 yo booze, or something bottled in 1975. He's a whiskey/bourbon drinker but that doesn't seem to exist, at least not for the few hundred $$ I want to spend. Any Brandy or Cognac experts here who can suggest the right bottle?
 
Port wine is also nice. Even folks who aren't big alcohol consumers usually enjoy a good port. It's pretty easy to find something old and decent that won't break the bank.

 
If you’re looking for a 50yr age statement, that’s rarer than hen’s teeth when it comes to Scotch, Bourbon, and other whisk(e)y. That’s lost barrel territory.

Finding a birth year distillation or production bottle can be a bit easier, but you’re looking at the secondary markets for that. You run into the problem of not knowing what was a good bottle that year, so you’re kind of hoping to hit a home run without knowing what team you’re playing against, much less which pitcher.

The gesture is certainly kind, but if I got a birth year bottle, it’d get put away as a show piece and not as a drinker.

You might consider gifting a membership and mystery bottle in the Scotch Malt Whisky Society of America.

 
I would just get him a good bottle of your choosing, forget the 50 connotation. I just like to simplify, for the $$, you can probably do better than if held to the 50 yr connection.
 
I can’t help you much with the cognac or brandy, though I do also see some 1975 Armagnac bottles at reasonable prices. But really, I just wanted to drop in and tell you that I turn 65 in a couple of weeks…. friend…. pal… I mean, sure, we’ve never met, but still…
 
I like @GeorgeC ’s idea or some variation. Keeps you within budget and will be appreciated for age, quality, and variety. The 3-4 bottles can be used for taste testing excuses at any occasion.

Are kids born in ‘75 really turning 50? WTF!
 
I'm not a port drinker. Do you have any suggestions?
Nobody who sells a 50 yr old port wine is going to be making swill. You can pretty much decide what you want to spend, and pick up a bottle at that price, and have confidence you're giving a nice gift. That said, Taylor Fladgate is classic (do not confuse Taylor Fladgate for the similar-sounding "Taylor's" in the US--the former is Portuguese and is world-renowned (and commonly referred to as simply "Taylor" or "Taylor's" outside the US), the latter is $8/bottle NY stuff that's not what you're looking for). Kopke is also pretty classic. Both of those labels are pretty easy to find, though 50 yr bottles may not just be sitting on the shelf at your neighborhood liquor store. But like I say, any 50 yr-old port is going to be something special.

You're in Texas...do you have a Spec's nearby? If so, try visiting and asking for an appropriate gift for a 50th birthday, and see what they suggest. I'm in Houston and have access to their home base downtown, which is like the Home Depot of alcohol and staffed with really knowledgeable and helpful folks, but I've also gotten very good help from the staff in my local neighborhood Spec's too. Not sure if their staff at far-flung outposts are as consistently reliable, but it's worth a shot if you've got one close. I've also had good luck placing special orders at my local store and them transferring the product from wherever they had it to get it to me.
 
Nobody who sells a 50 yr old port wine is going to be making swill. You can pretty much decide what you want to spend, and pick up a bottle at that price, and have confidence you're giving a nice gift. That said, Taylor Fladgate is classic (do not confuse Taylor Fladgate for the similar-sounding "Taylor's" in the US--the former is Portuguese and is world-renowned (and commonly referred to as simply "Taylor" or "Taylor's" outside the US), the latter is $8/bottle NY stuff that's not what you're looking for). Kopke is also pretty classic. Both of those labels are pretty easy to find, though 50 yr bottles may not just be sitting on the shelf at your neighborhood liquor store. But like I say, any 50 yr-old port is going to be something special.

You're in Texas...do you have a Spec's nearby? If so, try visiting and asking for an appropriate gift for a 50th birthday, and see what they suggest. I'm in Houston and have access to their home base downtown, which is like the Home Depot of alcohol and staffed with really knowledgeable and helpful folks, but I've also gotten very good help from the staff in my local neighborhood Spec's too. Not sure if their staff at far-flung outposts are as consistently reliable, but it's worth a shot if you've got one close. I've also had good luck placing special orders at my local store and them transferring the product from wherever they had it to get it to me.
Thanks. We do have Spec's, and Total Wine. I'll have to check out the Port sections.
 
There likely is a lot more red wines which are 50 years old available and still taste good. But I like the idea of a port.

Now this has me wondering, my dad turns 80 in few weeks and my grandmother who I ma visiting right now turns 108 in a couple months. I wonder what the options would be to get them a drink made the year they were born.

Tim
 
I like @GeorgeC ’s idea or some variation. Keeps you within budget and will be appreciated for age, quality, and variety. The 3-4 bottles can be used for taste testing excuses at any occasion.

Are kids born in ‘75 really turning 50? WTF!
Man, I drove in my first race in '75.

I wore a full face helmet and the other drivers thought that was too much. But I was in blue jeans and a white t-shirt like everyone else...
 
"There is some Red Port wine Left."

I'm teaching a ground school segment next Sunday that includes aircraft lighting.

Also, turpentine is much cheaper than Armagnac and it tastes the same.
 
A good friend is turning 50 and I was thinking to get him some 50 yo booze, or something bottled in 1975. He's a whiskey/bourbon drinker but that doesn't seem to exist, at least not for the few hundred $$ I want to spend. Any Brandy or Cognac experts here who can suggest the right bottle?
My younger brother bought me and my twin a bottle of 50 year tawny port for our birthday, and we all drunk it together. It was delicious. Port is a fair bit sweeter than bourbon, but I think he'll like it.
 
I do enjoy a good port, and I suspect your friend will, too.

Go to https://vintageportsite.com/ and drag the slider on the left down to 1975.

BTW, there are some traditions that go with port, like passing the bottle clockwise around the table, that can make it a ceremony for you.
 
Are kids born in ‘75 really turning 50? WTF!
Given that my wife and I celebrated our 52nd wedding anniversary earlier this summer, as scary as that sounds, yep. Kids born in 1975 are tuning 50 this year. Our son will hit 49 later this year. Gad, we're getting old.
 
Examples of 50-year-old brandies

  • Ararat Erebuni 50 Year Old Brandy: An Armenian brandy that costs around $1,600 to over $2,400.
  • Bhakta 50 Year Old Brandy: A limited edition blended brandy from a mix of historic vintages (1868–1970). Some barrels have been released for as little as $299.
  • Courvoisier Fine Champagne Cognac 50 Years Old (1930s bottling): A rare, decades-old bottling of this famous cognac sold for around $3,500.
  • Hermitage 50 Year Old Grande Champagne Cognac: This cognac was awarded the Cognac Trophy and a Gold Outstanding Award in 2021 and sells for thousands of dollars.

Somehow I lost the link to the article.
 
If you go with the port, learn how to open the bottle using heated port tongs to add a little flair to the process.
 
Examples of 50-year-old brandies

  • Ararat Erebuni 50 Year Old Brandy: An Armenian brandy that costs around $1,600 to over $2,400.
  • Bhakta 50 Year Old Brandy: A limited edition blended brandy from a mix of historic vintages (1868–1970). Some barrels have been released for as little as $299.
  • Courvoisier Fine Champagne Cognac 50 Years Old (1930s bottling): A rare, decades-old bottling of this famous cognac sold for around $3,500.
  • Hermitage 50 Year Old Grande Champagne Cognac: This cognac was awarded the Cognac Trophy and a Gold Outstanding Award in 2021 and sells for thousands of dollars.

Somehow I lost the link to the article.
The Bhakta would be in my budget, but I'm curious about it being a "mix" of vintages.
 
The Bhakta would be in my budget, but I'm curious about it being a "mix" of vintages.
If your friend was conceived the year before he was born, you can argue that he is also a mix of vintages and the Bhakta is appropriate
 
Now this has me wondering, my dad turns 80 in few weeks
A few years ago, my Kiwi son in law Andy's parents visited from Australia, where they then lived. Along the way, they stopped in Scotland, where she was originally from, and visited her relatives who own the Longmorn distillery. Knowing I like a good single malt, they asked for a bottle for me. They tapped an 80 year old cask (!) for her, and gave her a hand labeled bottle, which miraculously made it through customs inside a Glenlivet box. All I can say is wow... I had to buy a bottle of a more recent Longmorn vintage to have something to properly compare it to, and still wow. After the first few glasses, I saved the rest in a cool dark place and poured one glass each year on Christmas until it was gone, a toast to Andy's father who passed shortly after the visit. I can still hear her thick Scottish brogue, "I'm family, otherwise that would have been an 800 pound bottle!"
 
Thanks. We do have Spec's, and Total Wine. I'll have to check out the Port sections.
Like I say, you're unlikely to find a 50yr bottle sitting on the shelf. Be sure to talk to the folks in the store and let them know what you're looking for--I'm sure they'll do their best to help you.
 
Knowing I like a good single malt, they asked for a bottle for me. They tapped an 80 year old cask (!) for her, and gave her a hand labeled bottle
I’ve had a glass of 25 year old Macallan, and can only imagine - no, strike that, cannot even imagine an 80 year old single malt. That must have been divine.
 
Back
Top