For a 172E landplane, you're stuck with this prop unless you have an STC that allows something else:
1. Propeller Propeller Limits (a) McCauley 1C172/EM 7652, 53
Static rpm at maximum permissible throttle setting: Not over 2420, not under 2230
No additional tolerance permitted
Diameter: not over 76 in., not under 74.5 in.
So you can have a 1C172/EM 76x52 or 76x53 inch pitch, and that's it. 53 would appear to be a cruise prop.