Private Pilot checkride, tosses a prop blade

wow. Most realistic test I've ever heard of.
 
Wow. I always wondered what the examiner's reaction to that would be. I can imagine a few saying "yes, you did well on that emergency landing, but we still haven't done a steep turn..."

Nice job to the pilot.
 
But did he flunk the preflight? :dunno:

Kudos to the new private pilot!

-Skip
 
http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/31406251/detail.html

Landed in a field near KLMO without further incident.

Wow. The quote from Drew (the DPE, many of us know him here) is classic...

"He demonstrated his competency, he passed."

Guess that'll be a great war story, for both of them!

I know both involved. Test was in the owner's LSA that has a wood prop. Drew wrote up the report for the NTSB and the FAA. The pilot's going to write up the story for thr Colorado Pilots newsletter. A better article is in the Longmont Times-Call newspaper.
 
I wonder who was at the controls during the landing. I know the applicant is PIC, but if it were me, I would ask the DPE to take over since he's obviously much more experienced and you only get one chance during a real engine out landing.
 
I wonder who was at the controls during the landing. I know the applicant is PIC, but if it were me, I would ask the DPE to take over since he's obviously much more experienced and you only get one chance during a real engine out landing.
I was wondering the same thing. I would expect the DPE to take over for an actual emergency, though I COULD see him monitoring the situation and not doing anything if the applicant was properly handling it. Not much room for error, though. :yikes:
 
I'd say it would depend on the size of the landing field available. Some are large enough they provide a large room for error.

Also remember DPE's and cfi's have a lot of experience 'monitoring' a student and taking over before things get out of hand
 
Last edited:
I was wondering the same thing. I would expect the DPE to take over for an actual emergency, though I COULD see him monitoring the situation and not doing anything if the applicant was properly handling it. Not much room for error, though. :yikes:

It's entirely possible that the DPE has absolutely no experience what-so-ever landing that LSA power-off...entirely possible that ride is the first time the DPE has even been in the type. It's just hard to say.
 
I was wondering the same thing. I would expect the DPE to take over for an actual emergency, though I COULD see him monitoring the situation and not doing anything if the applicant was properly handling it. Not much room for error, though. :yikes:

Part of my "passenger brief" on my checkride, and every time I fly with a more experience pilot to this day is:
"If we experience an emergency, I will continue to fly the plane. If you feel you can better handle the situation, speak up, and I'll gladly yield to the more experienced pilot. However, please don't just just grab the controls. I will not presume you are taking control at any time unless you ask!"
 
I'm guessing they had completed all tasks except the simulated (or not-so-simulated) power loss / forced landing; otherwise it'd be an incomplete. :)
 
To eliminate any speculation here, I quote a private email from the pilot to me:

" I saw the whole process very much as a team effort. While I may have flown the plane all the way, I was definitely listening to his orders when they were issued."
 
It's entirely possible that the DPE has absolutely no experience what-so-ever landing that LSA power-off...entirely possible that ride is the first time the DPE has even been in the type. It's just hard to say.

I know the DPE... there's zero doubt in my mind he could have flown it VERY well.

He suffers from degenerative rheumatoid arthritis in his hands, but never once let that stop him flying anything with wings.

I might be willing to speculate that utilizing the applicant as his hands while giving guidance was probably just the simplest form of crew coordination in the moment.

It'll be interesting to read the story.

He's truly an asset to the local aviation community. After he learns that someone in the area has attained their IR (especially if they took their ride with him, of course, since that's an easy list), he puts their aircraft and name on a list and as he joked, "works his way down the list from most interesting aircraft to least interesting" whenever flyable Actual pops up around here, offering to jump in and teach/coach anyone who needs the Actual time on a trip on a moment's notice, if he's available. He knows none of us here get enough Actual. As just one example of things I know he does.

When I first met him in the 90s, he was a CFI only, and later when I returned to aviation and heard he'd been appointed a DPE, the reaction was... "Wow. Of course he was." One of those rare folk you just know belongs doing that job.

It's really hard to catch him on the ground. He's booked solid with flying. No grass growing under that guy!
 
Back
Top