Poll to Pin-point Something Lost

tinerj

Cleared for Takeoff
Joined
Jul 1, 2012
Messages
1,350
Display Name
tinerj
Years ago, in the early days of the Internet, something went missing -- plane, boat, submarine, bomb, etc. My memory is fuzzy about just what. But the military, I think, set up a way on the Internet for people to place a marker on a map where they thought it might be.

Either by design or accident, ordinary people on the Internet could place their marker for its location. About 25,000 responded. Slowly as more results came it, the pin-points began to cluster. When they did the search at the center of the cluster, they found the missing object.

All right, I've searched the Internet and can find no reference to what I only vaguely remember. This was back in the days of AltaVista search and Mosaic Web browser.

For some reason, nothing like it was every tried again. (Tell me I'm wrong because it seems like a good idea.)

Why it worked I have no solid idea. Perhaps during the early days of the Internet it was difficult to trace back who posted the "good" pinpoints, so those working at the grunt level posted them because their Stupidvisors at a higher level dismissed their ideas.

Seems like if something like this could be done for Flight 370, it might open up some possibilities.

By the way, a recent analysis of comments on twitter found the comments are running a couple of days AHEAD of the official line. It seems, somehow, a large group of people, including some that may be clueless, can converge on useful information.
 
They did the crowd source search for Steve Fossett.

I've been on the Internet since before there was a WWW and don't recall anything like that, but my memory could be faulty.
 
"I have a great memory, except for anything that deals with the past."
 
THe whole APB or BOLO thingy the police use. Or Amber alerts. Or 10 most wanted (which worked well for Whitey Bulger even though it took 17 years).
Supposedly the black agencies would lock people in a room and have them think of stuff they are looking for then sift through the stream of consciousness upchuck for clues. Iirc one of Malcolm Gladwell's books talks about it, and professors playing around with it. It is all voodoo malarkey with some occasional successes thrown in.
 
The example I heard was "group wisdom" for things like guessing how many jellybeans in a big jar: Any individual guess was probably way off but the aggregate from the mass crowd was pretty spot on.

In the examples, though, the crowd had all the relevant info they would need. Easy for jellybeans, not so easy for MA370.
 
Back
Top