Control/Reciprocating Engines – Float-type Carburetors

RotorAndWing

Final Approach
Joined
Sep 5, 2008
Messages
8,496
Location
Other side of the world
Display Name

Display name:
Rotor&Wing
FAA
Aircraft Certification Service
SPECIAL AIRWORTHINESS
INFORMATION BULLETIN
SAIB: NE-10-05
SUBJ: Control/Reciprocating Engines – Float-type Carburetors Date: October 16, 2009
This is information only. Recommendations aren’t mandatory.
Introduction
This Special Airworthiness Information Bulletin (SAIB) alerts you, pilots, owners, operators,
maintenance personnel, and certificated repair facilities of reciprocating aircraft engines with
float-type carburetors, of potential hazards associated with those carburetors. At this time, the
airworthiness concern is not an unsafe condition that would warrant airworthiness directive (AD)
action under Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) part 39.
Background
This SAIB results from reports of numerous accidents and incidents over the past 20 years that
resulted from an engine stoppage or engine fire involving float-type carburetors. Numerous service
information letters (SILs) and service bulletins (SBs) were issued during that time to address floattype
carburetor issues related to poor idle cut-off and fuel leaking from the carburetor after engine
shutdown. The FAA issued SAIB CE-06-33R1 in April 2006 to address those conditions. These
conditions are often the result of fuel leaking into the carburetor float, a damaged or worn float, or a
damaged or worn float valve. Despite the availability of the SILs and SBs, the FAA is still receiving
reports of accidents and incidents resulting from carburetor float anomalies. In comparison to the
SILs and SBs previously issued, this SAIB is applicable to all aircraft with reciprocating engines with
float-type carburetors installed and provides more detail and focused recommended actions.
Carburetor float design has evolved over the past 20 years, resulting in many different types of floats
in service today. Carburetor floats are primarily made from polymers (plastics), brass, or epoxy
“foam”. The buoyancy of a float is typically provided by either a cavity, or cavities, that are formed
by a thin outer shell of polymer, brass, or epoxy. If this shell is compromised, the result is a breach
that permits fuel to enter the cavity, which reduces the buoyancy of the float. The shell can be
compromised in several ways such as:
• Cracking
• Separating at a weld seam, soldered seam, or joint
• A hole.
A hole can be caused by the shell rubbing on the carburetor bowl. The shell might rub on the
carburetor bowl due to excessive pivot wear, which affects the alignment and operation of the float
and metering components. If the float buoyancy is reduced, it can lead to improper metering of fuel to
the engine and/or fuel leaking from the carburetor. These conditions can then lead to complete loss of
power or engine fires. Some newer float designs are fabricated from closed cell epoxy material.
These floats are more tolerant to rubbing, chafing, and cutting since the buoyancy is provided by
thousands of independent closed cells rather than a few closed cells.
Carburetors are commonly maintained only when problems warrant their repair or overhaul.
However, it is recommended by engine type certificate holders that carburetors be overhauled at the
engine's overhaul interval. If this is not done, the airworthiness of the carburetor can deteriorate and
eventually cause a severe hazard to operation.
2
Applicable model list: All aircraft with reciprocating engines with float-type carburetors installed.
Recommendations
• Pilot Action:
During preflight inspections, examine the engine area for evidence of fuel leakage. During
engine start, be alert for carburetor flooding or the need for excessive leaning. Hard starting
might be an indicator of a deteriorating or damaged carburetor float. During engine operation,
excessive fuel consumption and/or poor idle performance might indicate a deteriorating or
damaged carburetor float. Difficulty shutting down the engine with the mixture cut-off control
might be an indicator of a deteriorating or damaged carburetor float. If any of these conditions
are observed, the pilot should have qualified maintenance personnel inspect the aircraft before
the next flight.
• Owner, Operator, and Maintenance Personnel Action:
Perform routine carburetor inspections for signs of fuel leakage. Inspect for fuel stains from
the bowl vents in the throat of the carburetor and/or fuel in the air box. Comply with all
engine and carburetor manufacturer recommendations, including, but not limited to,
maintenance procedures, SBs, Customer Bulletins, SILs, etc. Maintenance Personnel
addressing these issues should inspect the carburetor for signs of fuel leakage. Remove
carburetors with signs of fuel leakage and send them to a qualified repair station for overhaul,
inspection, and repair.
• Overhaul Action:
Overhaul the carburetor at every engine overhaul interval. The correct interval to use is
whichever of the following occurs first:
• The engine manufacturer’s recommended interval
• 12 years
• 2,400 hours
During overhaul, inspect the float and float valve. Replace with a new float and float valve as
necessary.
For Further Information Contact
Mr. Sanford Proveaux, Aerospace Engineer, Atlanta Aircraft Certification Office, FAA, Small
Airplane Directorate, Propulsion and Services Branch, 1701 Columbia Avenue, College Park, GA
30337; telephone (404) 474-5566; fax (404) 474-5606; e-mail: sanford.proveaux@faa.gov.
 
Wow, the FAA figured out that floatbowls can stick. I'm impressed. Next they might figure that that it gets dark at night.
 
Last edited:
Wow, the FAA figured out that floatbowls can stick. I'm pressed. Next they might figure that that it gets dark at night.

Yes, me too, and remember, they want you to send a perfectly good carb to Kelly Areospace so they can screw it up for you.

there is only one wear spot in the whole carb, the throttle shaft to bushings. the bushings are 19 cents each.
 
what a bunch of ....well they said it best themselves:
• A hole.

A hole can be caused by



Be thankful they didn't make it an AD requiring replacement of the entire fleet's carburetors at 'minimal inconvenience and expense to owners'!!
 
what a bunch of ....well they said it best themselves:




Be thankful they didn't make it an AD requiring replacement of the entire fleet's carburetors at 'minimal inconvenience and expense to owners'!!

Run the AD list on carb.


98-01-06 Model MA-3A, MA-3PA, MA-3SPA, MA-4 SPA, Carburetor venturi - Precision Airmotive
94-25-04 Model HA-6 Series Carburetors - Precision Airmotive
93-19-04 Model MA-3, MA3A, MA-3PA, MA-3SPA, MA-4SPA Carburetor float - Precision Airmotive
93-18-03 Model MA-3A, MA-3PA, MA-3SPA, MA-4 SPA, Carburetor venturi - Superseded by AD 98-01-06 - Precision Airmotive
92-15-16 PL Model MA3, MA3A, MA3PA, MA3SPA, and MA4SPA carburetors - Facet Aerospace Products
89-04-02 Model MA-4-5, MA-5, MA-6AA Carburetors - Facet Aerospace Products
88-02-04 Model MA-3PA Carburetors - Facet Aerospace Products
80-08-14 Carburetor air inlet filter - Pure-Air, Inc.
79-08-06 Model HA-6 Series carburetors - Marvel-Schebler
77-13-16 Model HA-6 Series carburetors - Marvel-Schebler
72-06-05 R2 Models MA-3, MA-3PA, MA-3SPA, MA-4SPA, MA-4-5, MA-4-5-AA, MA-5, MA-6AA, HA-6 Series carburetors - Marvel-Schebler
69-24-03 Models MA-3A, MA-3PA, MA-3SPA, MA-4SPA, MA-4-5, MA-4-5-AA, MA-5, MA-6AA, HA-6 Series carburetors - Marvel-Schebler
63-22-03 Model MA-4-5 Series
 
This is an SAIB, basically a reminder or duplication of what we already have in ADs. Some bureaucrat somewhere has to justify their job.

This is how half of those ADs started. Its Lawyers selling parts. they write a SB then scream safety, and bingo the AD appears.
 
Back
Top