Comanche 180/250

Fransisco

Filing Flight Plan
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Messages
21
Location
Knoxville , Tn
Display Name

Display name:
Francisco McClain
I'm new to the Comanche but absolutely love them . I've found a 180 that I would like to purchase for spare parts, since it is not rebuildable , for my 250. Are the chassis parts the same leaving only the engine as the primary difference ?

Thanks to all!!
 
Last edited:
Yep. Same airframe for the most part. There may be subtle differences between your 250 and the 180 depending on the serial numbers. The parts and service manuals are available on the web if you search hard enough.
 
A bigger issue is the year, rather than 180/250. Piper made a lot of rolling changes during production, not always lined up with model year.
 
I'm new to the Comanche but absolutely love them . I've found a 180 that I would like to purchase for spare parts, since it is not rebuildable , for my 250. Are the chassis parts the same leaving only the engine as the primary difference ?

Thanks to all!!

The airframe is pretty much the same. However, most of them don't really wear out or are repairable.

If you want to connect with the Comanche community online, there is the Airworthy Comanche forum on Delphi.
 
I'm new to the Comanche but absolutely love them . I've found a 180 that I would like to purchase for spare parts, since it is not rebuildable , for my 250. Are the chassis parts the same leaving only the engine as the primary difference ?

Thanks to all!!

What parts are you hoping to salvage?
 
Id just like to have spare parts for mine that maybe rebuilt including landing gear transmission etc if they are the same . Currently the plane is out in the weather so I was thinking of disaasembly and placing in warehouse for storage and discarding parts that are utterly destroyed ..
 
Id just like to have spare parts for mine that maybe rebuilt including landing gear transmission etc if they are the same . Currently the plane is out in the weather so I was thinking of disaasembly and placing in warehouse for storage and discarding parts that are utterly destroyed ..

That's a good plan if the deal is right, what do you plan to do with the sheet metal components?
 
MLG trunions, nose gear assembly, gear motor and trans if it's a Duke's, flap motor and trans are all very valuable. Wings, tailfeathers and much are more common, simply because the bird was alodined inside when manufactured, so corrosion is very rarelly an issue. There are a few other items, but a good Dukes trans is worth holding onto. The wheels and brakes are pricey too.

Out of curiosity, what happened to it that makes it A total loss?
 
Last edited:
If you are going to dispose of the sheet metal for scrap, there's a trick to it. You see, the recycling yards hate airframes and it has to do with the rivets, not sure why, but I've done a couple now, and it's been that way, so you have a bit of work to put in cutting out the aluminum panels from between the rivet lines.

The best way to do this is I found is with a 4 or 4.5" pneumatic 90° cut-off/grinder and a Multi-Cutter blade. Basically a ripsaw blade for non ferrous metals. You have to be careful with this rig. It has to be pneumatic, yes, you'll need to buy or rent a compressor. You can actually rent the whole rig for a week cheap enough. Never use a little electric grinder for this, they have too much torque, and when they catch (and they do) the results are often tragic. A pneumatic one just stops with barely a twitch, it has no real spinning mass or torque to the motor. We use this rig building aluminum boats to cut and fit plates and components. If ever an apprentice was seen with an electric rig, he was fired on the spot and escorted off. Either he slept through the in doc video on the use and dangers of the Multi Cutter, or he wasn't impressed with carnage that was documented there in.

What I do is cut and stack all the clean aluminum in one load and get premium recycle value for it, then haul in the crumpled load of seams and rivet lines and take the discount price on it. Otherwise I take the discount price on the whole thing, and the difference has always been significant enough to be worth the effort.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top