This is your statement. I see you are trying to thread the needle with your explanation but you are failing to admit two things:
every policy you renew charges you for a windshield that you most likely never use. On top of that, unless you live in one of THREE states there is a required payment you have to make for the coverage you don't seem to want to admit to.
Perhaps I pay for a portion of a windshield with each renewal rather than the whole thing. I've used the service a few times and it just worked, wherever I chose to have the window fixed. I always admitted that I pay for better service. Someone runs into me just before a business trip? The car is ready upon my return. My wife hits a deer while I'm gone? She takes it to a dealer and it is fixed upon my return.
It's my money and I can spend it as I wish.
You are NOT PAYING FOR A SERVICE. You are paying to shift the cost of the repair. And you will never, ever win.
Insurance is indeed a service. I'm spreading the risk for the financial loss both over time and a pool of other people they pay that insurance company. No one, except the insurer, is trying to win, as any business wants to profit from product or services. I just want the glass fixed or replaced.
You rate HAS INCREASED: by adding comprehensive and paying for a zero deductible glass rider you paid up front. You may not be paying at the time you replace your glass, but you are 100% paying every time you renew your policy.
You know perfectly know that's not what I meant. I make a premium payment, I get broken glass, the insurer pays for the repair. For me, the premium doesn't increase in the next billing cycle for that single event compared to the previous premium. I know you understood that how I meant it.
Your insurance carrier is 1000000% tracking your claims. They are not a charity and if you are cracking glass above what the spreadsheet calculates as a loss you will see 1. a rate increase or 2. a denial of coverage. That's just how insurance works. Its all about how much you take out vs what you are putting in.
Yes, that's how actuarial tables work. The vast majority of us don't get into that situation, with exceptions for poor drivers.
As for all this talk about convenience.. lol wut? You had to wait a day? You had to drive to a shop? That's for the common folks. Safelite did it in two hours, at my home. At the day and time I chose.
I drove to the shop. I could either walk 200 meters to my house, or the dealer drove me to work and picked me up at the end of the day. "Common folk" use Safelite, too.
I checked my policy (Progressive) and adding comprehensive with a $100 deductable and a $50 glass rider increases my premuim for a 2014 Grand Caravan by
Total premium increase: $184.03
for a 6 month policy.
So by YOUR math ("no rate increase") that's simply not true. You are just betting 'against the house' and your blind is $184 a hand. In 4 years I replaced one windshield for $250-ish dollars... but by YOUR math I would get glass for $0.... becuase in those 4 years I bet ($184.03 * 2 renewals a year * 4 years) $1472.
I see you are cherry-picking data. Try a more typical $500 deductible. You are also twisting my words- I never said that "...would get glass for $0". In any case, I'm wasn't faulting you for the manner of your repair. I simply noted that you misrepresented how some insurance policies work.
So LITTERALLY, by your maths, a free windshield would only cost me $1472. And you still have to give up your car for a day.
Again, you either aren't reading the posts here or you are misrepresenting what is posted as well as facts- I never said the windshield was "free". I don't need the car for a day as I mentioned above.
WOW! Insurance really is your friend!
And the neat part is if I have a high end vehicle, the comprehensive coverage is still a huge loss as the premuim will rise proportional to the known repair costs.
I can see why the Snap-on guy doesn't like working with you. If I were him, I'd point you in the direction of the MATCO truck too.
Again, My money, my time. Not yours. Someone posted their dissatisfaction with a new $170K car in another thread. It's his money and I don't have any reason to tell him how to spend it.