I've been pretty happy with my Canon laser MFC. The only downside is their customer support is non-existant. The good thing is that there has been not much cause for me to ever even attempt to contact them.
For 2000 pages a month, I'd agree. The MFCs are tanks. HP stuff is fine too.
We also have quite a bit of Xerox stuff on lease that works well but we have much much much higher page counts than you're describing.
The scanner stuff will make you insane in a corporate environment if the printer doesn't have enough smarts to simply email someone a copy of their scan, preferably in PDF. Any off-printer/server software WILL be a problem, eventually, even if it isn't on day one. (Think forced OS upgrades and what not... Something always breaks on that crap and REAL software support on any printer older than three years often is non-existent.)
Really look hard at your true scanning needs and if it's really only a small group of people, consider getting the group a nice scanner or multifunction just for them, and plopping it down somewhere close.
I'm surprised at the need for five printers for a 2000 sheet a month environment, too. Depends on office layout and walking distance I suppose.
The vast vast majority of our way more than 10,000 pages a month flows through that single big leased Xerox and it has the ability to scan to an email and also to scan into pre-defined Windows/CIFS network shares with one button press, once we configure it. Four different groups scan to their shared file areas on a NAS with it.
A couple of execs have inexpensive HP printers in their offices and I'd be amazed if either prints a full team of paper every month. Accounting has another small HP and they give it a workout, but it was so cheap it can be replaced at any time with a trip to a local store with a credit card.
We also run a full digital print shop out back, but that's a completely different story. A laser printer that uses roll paper that has to be brought to it with a forklift. Heh. It doesn't scan, amazingly enough! Ha.