So, I've done a lot of reading and have done limited trials of both. I'm mostly interested in feedback from someone who has tried both, on an IPAD. Ideally somewhat recently, as I think the newest version of GP added a lot. Me: 13 hour student Plane I'll be flying for the foreseeable future: 172/182 with 430WAAS. Owners will handle ADSB mandates, so I don't need to factor that into my decision. Own an IPad Air 2 with GPS/Cellular data So, I won't need the application for navigation. I'd use it for preflight planning, perhaps during flight to look up frequencies/weather/etc. I'm sure this has been hashed a lot, but honestly, none of the discussions I'd seen were very recent, and VERY few people seem to have tried both on an apple product.