Helicopter Down in East River

Ah, money is the reason....

Three up front in an A-star sounds awfully cramped, but I guess that is how they can make the prices for these rides work.
With a L/H PIC it's not bad. A double seat with a R/H PIC not--that seat is a good 8-10" narrower. Latest I heard though it was not a L/H PIC aircraft.
 
Oh boy, looks like the politicians are already pointing fingers and trying to "do something"

Haven’t seen that but they will do something after this one is analyzed. Let’s see, the tourist passengers are strapped in AND tethered with tether requiring a knife for an emergency (underwater) exit. No cost effective briefing can overcome that when this happens.

Oh, the pilot, presumably not tethered but briefed and experienced, is the only person to survive .

It will be particularly ugly if one or more passenger were released from their straps but still tethered when found by divers.

Of course none of us know what really happened yet.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
 
Now they are saying it's possible a passengers bag shut of the fuel control. Possible since it was a B2 model.
 
Haven’t seen that but they will do something after this one is analyzed. Let’s see, the tourist passengers are strapped in AND tethered with tether requiring a knife for an emergency (underwater) exit. No cost effective briefing can overcome that when this happens.

Oh, the pilot, presumably not tethered but briefed and experienced, is the only person to survive .

It will be particularly ugly if one or more passenger were released from their straps but still tethered when found by divers.

Of course none of us know what really happened yet.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

Those tethers should have some sort of a quick release to facilitate emergency egress. Something along the lines of a three ring release with a bright red handle that the pax can easily pull in an emergency.
 
3 accidents in 11 years for that chopper charter... clearly you know more about it than everyone. ;)
I know nothing about the charter company which is why I haven’t made any comment. I was talking about Schumer not knowing what he’s talking about and what I beliveve to be the general stupidity of most of our political leaders. You can agree or not but my conclusions are based on fact not emotion or what some biased bobble head “reports” on the news. Now I’ll bow out because this is walking a fine line on the forum rules.
 
I know nothing about the charter company which is why I haven’t made any comment. I was talking about Schumer not knowing what he’s talking about and what I beliveve to be the general stupidity of most of our political leaders. You can agree or not but my conclusions are based on fact not emotion or what some biased bobble head “reports” on the news. Now I’ll bow out because this is walking a fine line on the forum rules.
I know our political system is in crisis and too many of our political leaders are corrupt, lack integrity or are perhaps wrong headed, but facts supporting their "stupidity" may be difficult to list and defend. Few if any of our leaders are slow, simple minded or lack intelligence. Seriously

And there's some pretty good reporting going on if you select your sources with some intelligence. There's also a crap load of lousy reporting going on, no doubt.
 
Haven’t seen that but they will do something after this one is analyzed. Let’s see, the tourist passengers are strapped in AND tethered with tether requiring a knife for an emergency (underwater) exit. No cost effective briefing can overcome that when this happens.

Oh, the pilot, presumably not tethered but briefed and experienced, is the only person to survive .

It will be particularly ugly if one or more passenger were released from their straps but still tethered when found by divers.

Of course none of us know what really happened yet.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro


Except for facts and stuff, like how many hours flown per accident like this, sadly some cupcakes still think they are owed a "safe" world when that ain't no such animal, no matter how hard the government markets it.


Personally my only change would be for a pocket with a hook knife to be stitched onto each harness, probably on the shoulder strap, done and done.

Also I'm a big fan of having some type of hook knife in anything you're belted into.






jackhookknife1of4_copy.jpg

http://www.chutingstar.com/jack-the-ripper-hook-knife






I’m surprised he even knows what a 135 is.

66269572.jpg



I'm sure some staffer googled it for him, politicians never let a good death count go to waste when it can help them in the next election
 
Trying to understand: They were strapped in with belts that probably had a quick release, but because the doors were off they were also tethered?

And the tethers don't have a quick release because that could be a bad thing if you fell out, so they needed to be either cut or somehow unclipped?

Where on your body would that tether be attached? Would they have been wearing some sort of harness?
 
Except for facts and stuff, like how many hours flown per accident like this, sadly some cupcakes still think they are owed a "safe" world when that ain't no such animal, no matter how hard the government markets it.


Personally my only change would be for a pocket with a hook knife to be stitched onto each harness, probably on the shoulder strap, done and done.

Also I'm a big fan of having some type of hook knife in anything you're belted into.






jackhookknife1of4_copy.jpg

http://www.chutingstar.com/jack-the-ripper-hook-knife








66269572.jpg



I'm sure some staffer googled it for him, politicians never let a good death count go to waste when it can help them in the next election

That hook knife decent quality? Might order one of those.
 
That hook knife decent quality? Might order one of those.

Yes, I've used that same model to cut a floor belt in a drop zone plane when a jumper got snagged, 240lb ish guy hanging just beneath the door from his belt, cut like nothing, after he landed he had a photo of him holding the buckle that snagged his leg harness lol
 
From the picture I saw , it was a body harness similar to what construction workers use, with the attachment being in the center of the back.
 
Trying to understand: They were strapped in with belts that probably had a quick release, but because the doors were off they were also tethered?

And the tethers don't have a quick release because that could be a bad thing if you fell out, so they needed to be either cut or somehow unclipped?

Where on your body would that tether be attached? Would they have been wearing some sort of harness?
Looks like they may have been attached to the ring on their back (!!) We'll find out I'm sure.
helicopter-Artboard_1_copy_2.jpg
 
Maybe the FAA should carve out an 'experimental' category for commercial 'extreme sport' flights. No guarantees, no promises, no NTSB back seat driving, just go for it!
 
Maybe the FAA should carve out an 'experimental' category for commercial 'extreme sport' flights. No guarantees, no promises, no NTSB back seat driving, just go for it!

Except those people look like NYC types and were probably more likely to be killed by getting run over by a cabbie, getting shot/stabbed or raped to death, or contracting some disease, than anything GA related, including [gasp!] flying with the doors off. Not sure how many of you have flown with doors off or open, but it's really not a big deal....at all.
 
Yea seems pretty overkill to be tethered into it like that...
 
Yea seems pretty overkill to be tethered into it like that...

Gotta remeber it's marketed to city people.

Many people down there grow to full size "adults" and never even learn to drive a car.

If it were Texas or in the country you probably could just use normal belts.

920x920.jpg
 
Gotta remeber it's marketed to city people.

Many people down there grow to full size "adults" and never even learn to drive a car.

If it were Texas or in the country you probably could just use normal belts.

I hate city folks almost as much as millenials.

JUST KIDDING :p
 
Personally my only change would be for a pocket with a hook knife to be stitched onto each harness, probably on the shoulder strap, done and done.

Also I'm a big fan of having some type of hook knife in anything you're belted into.

We carry a hook knife in our hang gliding harness, especially useful when aerotowing. If the primary and secondary releases fail or jam, you cut the line.

Yea seems pretty overkill to be tethered into it like that...

Except when excited passenger accidentally grabs the harness release and falls to his death. In all situations except for a water landing, redundant harnessing makes sense. And in the event of a water landing, even trained pilots have to move quickly to get out. These people were in a no win situation. Sucks, but that's the fact.
 
920x920.jpg


Them Duke boys, Bo and Luke along with Daisy learn a new way to antagonize Boss Hogg and Sherriff Roscoe P. Coltrane....
 
Last edited:
Gotta remeber it's marketed to city people.

Many people down there grow to full size "adults" and never even learn to drive a car.

If it were Texas or in the country you probably could just use normal belts.

920x920.jpg

I love Texas. :)
 
Schumer is calling on the FAA to pull their 135 cert.
Which company? The clients were for NYON, who have their own Astars, but this flight used a Liberty aircraft (different operator) and the flight was done under Part 91 Photo ops. Definitely a cluster....

Those tethers should have some sort of a quick release to facilitate emergency egress.
Personally my only change would be for a pocket with a hook knife to be stitched onto each harness,
It depends on the type of harness whether it is QD. Each harness in this aircraft had a webbing knife attached and its use was part of the pax brief. The harness was tethered to an aircraft hard point most likely a cargo ring on the floor.

The harnesses could also have been an insurance requirement in order to fly pax without doors.

If it were Texas or in the country you probably could just use normal belts.
Shotguns are easier and a lot more fun.
 
From the picture I saw , it was a body harness similar to what construction workers use, with the attachment being in the center of the back.

I just saw the pix posted above.

Yeah, unfamiliar pax, nobody ever really pays attention to the safety briefing anyway, helicopter hits, pax panic, release belts, jump out, maybe try to swim, finally (maybe) realize they are still tethered, panic even more, helicopter rolls over, the end.
 
I just saw the pix posted above.

Yeah, unfamiliar pax, nobody ever really pays attention to the safety briefing anyway, helicopter hits, pax panic, release belts, jump out, maybe try to swim, finally (maybe) realize they are still tethered, panic even more, helicopter rolls over, the end.
The helicopter started rolling when it ‘arrived’. Anybody not strapped in a seat was thrown to the low side to make sure the helicopter rolled further. In covered lifeboats that’s a really bad thing. In helicopters I bet it’s worse.
 
3 accidents in 11 years for that chopper charter... clearly you know more about it than everyone. ;)

I believe one was the mid-air between a helo and the Piper over the Hudson a few years back. The Piper basically overran the helo, and the controller watching the area was taking a personal phone call.
 
Except those people look like NYC types and were probably more likely to be killed by getting run over by a cabbie, getting shot/stabbed or raped to death, or contracting some disease, than anything GA related, including [gasp!] flying with the doors off. Not sure how many of you have flown with doors off or open, but it's really not a big deal....at all.

Let's see...
Skydived out of helicopters (and planes) .... check
Rappelled out of helicopters .... check
Door gunner practice ... check
Routinely sitting by the door during NOE ... check

So if I voice an opinion on it, I hope it will be considered an educated one.
 
Let's see...
Skydived out of helicopters (and planes) .... check
Rappelled out of helicopters .... check
Door gunner practice ... check
Routinely sitting by the door during NOE ... check

So if I voice an opinion on it, I hope it will be considered an educated one.

My comment was aimed towards the "extreme sport" comment about flying with the doors off.

He seems kind of slimy.

Pre req for being a senator in NY, look at the governor. I like NY, lots of great things and some good people, but there are some skeezy folks in government for sure.
 
The helicopter started rolling when it ‘arrived’. Anybody not strapped in a seat was thrown to the low side to make sure the helicopter rolled further. In covered lifeboats that’s a really bad thing. In helicopters I bet it’s worse.
The videos I saw stopped right about the time it went over on one side. I didn't see anything of how long it took to go all the way over or if anyone looked like they were able to get unbuckled but tangled up in the tethers or whatever else was going on. That would have sucked.
 
The videos I saw stopped right about the time it went over on one side. I didn't see anything of how long it took to go all the way over or if anyone looked like they were able to get unbuckled but tangled up in the tethers or whatever else was going on. That would have sucked.
In helicopter egress training they rolled the cage pretty quick. Dunno how close that is to reality. Doubt there is much of a righting moment once it lays on its side. Engines/transmission on one end, floats on other end just isn’t going to end well. On the other hand some of the big helicopters seem to do okay staying upright.
 
I wonder if the floats are airbus (eurocopter) design
 
Back
Top